Car rental companies

Car rental companies look alike on a booking site, but they differ in loyalty perks, how they treat young drivers and debit cards, extra-driver and mileage rules, and how easy it is to skip the counter. This grid compares the major US rental brands with the Turo marketplace and Zipcar car sharing, so you can see which fits your trip before you compare prices.

Last updated

How to choose

Terms here come from each company's public US policies. Many rules (minimum age, debit cards, additional drivers, fees) change by location and state, so check the rental terms for your exact pickup location before you book.

1. Pick the kind of rental

  • Rental companies (Enterprise, Hertz, Avis and the rest) rent from airport and neighborhood counters with standard cars, one-way options, and 24/7 support.
  • Turo is a marketplace: you rent a specific car from a private host, and rules, delivery, and mileage limits vary by host.
  • Zipcar is car sharing: you pay a membership, book by the hour or day, and pick the car up from a reserved spot.

2. Check who can rent

  • Most companies rent at 21 or older (18 in New York and Michigan) but charge a daily young renter fee until 25.
  • Paying with a debit card often needs extra ID, a credit check, or a larger deposit, and some airport locations don't allow it.
  • Adding a second driver usually costs extra per day, though spouses or partners are free at some companies or in some states.

3. Compare the total cost

  • Look at taxes, airport fees, the young renter fee, extra drivers, one-way drop fees, and fuel or charging rules, not just the daily rate.
  • Check mileage: most major rentals include unlimited miles, but some rates, Turo hosts, and car-sharing plans cap them.
  • Pay-later bookings are usually free to cancel; prepaid rates are cheaper but may charge a fee if plans change.

4. Decide on damage protection

  • The counter will offer a damage waiver. Before you buy it, check whether your own car insurance or credit card already covers rental cars, and whether that coverage is primary or secondary.

5. Join the free loyalty program

  • Free programs let you skip the counter at many airports and sometimes pick your own car. Sign up before you book.

Final check

Before you drive away, photograph the car, note the fuel or charge level, and confirm the return time and place.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide services and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the company doesn't publish it

FeatureService ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿
Company type
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Rental company
Peer-to-peer marketplace
Car sharing
⠿
Parent company
Enterprise Mobility
Enterprise Mobility
Enterprise Mobility
Hertz Global Holdings
The Hertz Corporation
Hertz
Avis Budget Group
Avis Budget Group
Avis Budget Group
Sixt SE
Europcar Mobility Group
Turo Inc. (independent)
Avis Budget Group
⠿
US locations
Thousands of US airport and neighborhood locations
308 US locations
247 US rental locations
Over 2,000 US neighborhood locations, plus airports
More than 260 locations in the US and Canada
Not stated
Numerous locations in all 50 states
1,444 US locations
About 120 locations across the US, Canada, Europe and South America
Hundreds of US locations, airports and downtown
About 28 US locations listed, mostly airports
Hosts in thousands of cities; no rental branches
25 cities and 300+ campuses across Europe and North America
⠿
Loyalty program
Enterprise Plus: earn points for free rental days, no blackout dates
Emerald Club: pick any car in the Emerald Aisle at the midsize rate
Alamo Insiders: 5% off pay-later base rates
Hertz Gold+: skip the line, members-only rates, points for free days
Dollar Express Rewards: points toward free days; skip the counter
Blue Chip Rewards: free; member rates, quicker pickup, spouse drives free
Avis Preferred: earn points and go straight to your car
Fastbreak: show your license, grab the keys and skip the line
Perks Club: free; member-only discounts and faster booking
SIXT ONE: member rates up to 20% off, points, skip the counter in the app
Fox Rewards: 4 points per $1 spent, redeemed as FoxBucks off rentals
None for guests
None; a paid membership plan is required to drive
⠿
Skip the counter
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Minimum renter age
21 years, Most states; 18 in Michigan and New York
21 years, Most states; 18 in Michigan and New York
21 years, Most states; 18 in Michigan and New York
20 years, Most states; 18 in NY and MI, 19 in AL and NE
20 years, Most states; 18 in NY and MI, 19 in AL and NE
20 years, 18 in New York and Michigan; 19 in Alabama and Nebraska
21 years, 18 in New York and Michigan
21 years, 18 in New York and Michigan
21 years, 25 without the young renter surcharge
21 years, 18 in New York and for government rentals
21 years, 18 for active-duty military on travel orders
18 years, Standard cars; higher for pricier cars (21, 25, or 30)
21 years, 18 in New York, Michigan, Maryland and on university accounts
⠿
Young renter fee
$25/day, Average; varies by location (higher in NY and MI)
$25/day, Average; varies by location (higher in NY and MI)
$25/day, Average; varies by location (higher in NY and MI)
$25/day, Most states; $52 a day in NY, MI, AL and NE
$25/day, Most states; $52 a day in NY, MI, AL and NE
$25/day, Most states; $52 a day in NY, MI, AL and NE
Varies by location; NY $35 and MI $28 a day for ages 21-24
$27/day, Most locations; varies in New York and Michigan
$25/day
Varies by location and car type
$22/day, Under 25, at Fox corporate locations
Under 25; amount varies by trip length and other factors
From $28/day, New York from $35 a day; hourly rates also apply
⠿
Additional driver fee
$15 a day ($5 in New York); spouse or domestic partner free
$15 a day ($5 in New York); spouse, partner and members' family free
$15 a day ($5 in New York); spouse or domestic partner free
Gold+ members' spouse or partner drives free; others may pay a fee
Fee varies by location; loyalty members' spouse or partner free
Fee varies by location; spouse or partner free for loyalty members
$13 a day in most states; spouse or partner free
$13 a day in most states; spouse or partner free
$13 a day per additional driver
Daily fee with a daily cap; waived where state law requires
$13.75 a day; spouse or domestic partner free at US corporate locations
$5 a day, capped at $25 per trip
Other drivers must be Zipcar members, e.g. on a family account
⠿
One way rentals
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
⠿
Cancellation policy
Pay later: free; prepaid: $50 fee, $100 within 24 hours of pickup
No payment taken at booking; cancel online or by phone
Pay later: free; Pay Now: $50 fee, $100 within 24 hours or no-show
Pay later: free; prepaid: $100, or $200 within 24 hours of pickup
Pay Now: $100 fee, $200 within 24 hours of pickup; capped at prepaid total
Prepaid: free within 24 hours of booking, then $100; $200 within 24 hours of pickup
Pay at counter: free; prepaid: $50 fee, $150 within 24 hours
Pay later: free ($75 if card-held and under 48 hours); prepaid: $50 fee, $150 within 24 hours
Pay later: cancel at least an hour ahead; prepaid: $50 fee, full loss under 48 hours
Pay later (Flexi): free until pickup; prepaid: free within 24 hours of booking, then a fee
Pay later: free; prepaid: full refund 48+ hours ahead, forfeited later
Refundable: free until 24 hours before; non-refundable: free 24 hours after booking
Free 24 hours ahead (3 hours for trips under 8 hours); later: no refund
⠿
Mileage
Unlimited on most car classes; limits on large vans, SUVs and exotics
Unlimited on US one-way rentals; specialty vans and large SUVs may be limited
Unlimited on most US rentals
Unlimited on most US rates; varies by rate and location
Unlimited on most US rentals; depends on car class and location
Depends on the rate; mileage charged only where the rate has it
Unlimited or a set daily allowance, depending on the rate
Unlimited mileage on one-way rentals at participating locations
Depends on the rate: unlimited or a set number of miles
Mileage package or unlimited, chosen at booking
Unlimited on many rentals; varies by location and booking
Set by each host; some include unlimited mileage
Up to 200 miles a day included; $0.67 a mile after
⠿
Debit cards accepted
Yes (Visa, Mastercard, Discover); airports need a return travel ticket
Yes (Visa, Mastercard, Discover); airports need a return travel ticket
Yes (Visa, Mastercard, Discover); airports need a return travel ticket
Yes (Visa, Mastercard, Discover) with ID, return ticket or credit check
Yes (Visa, Mastercard, Discover) with ID, return ticket or credit check
Yes with conditions (return ticket or 25+); $500 extra deposit
Yes at most locations (Visa/Mastercard); not for premium cars
At some locations, with a credit check or extra ID; 25+ only
Yes at most locations for standard cars; credit check, up to $300 hold
Yes at most locations; return ticket or proof of address; no luxury cars
Yes, with return flight itinerary and $500 deposit; not for locals
Yes: bank-issued Visa or Mastercard debit; may also need a credit card
Yes, major debit cards; no prepaid cards
⠿
Damage protection
Damage Waiver (DW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Collision Damage Waiver (CDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Protection packages: Basic, Smart, All-Inclusive (no deductible)
Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)
Protection plans (a physical damage contract, not insurance)
Damage protection (Plus or Premium) lowers the $2,500 damage fee
⠿
Roadside assistance
Roadside line free to call; optional paid RAP covers keys, lockouts, fuel
24/7; optional paid Roadside Plus covers keys, lockouts, tires, fuel
24/7; optional paid Roadside Plus covers keys, lockouts, tires, fuel
Optional paid Premium Emergency Roadside Service covers keys, tires, fuel
24/7 line; optional paid Premium Emergency Roadside Service
Basic help for breakdowns included; optional paid Premium Emergency Roadside Service
24/7; optional paid plan covers lockouts, flat tires and fuel
Optional paid Extended Roadside Assistance: lockouts, jump-starts, flat tires, fuel
24/7; optional paid Extended Roadside Assistance
24/7 roadside help for mechanical failure included
24/7 hotline; optional paid Emergency Roadside Assistance covers lockouts
24/7 included for breakdowns; paid Enhanced plan covers lockouts and fuel
24-hour, included; fee if caused by member error
⠿
Electric vehicles
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Yes
⠿
Mobile app
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Why these features matter

  • Company type

    Peer-to-peer and car-sharing services work differently from rental counters: insurance, pickup, and support depend on the host or membership.

  • Parent company

    Brands under one parent often share fleets, counters, and loyalty perks, so prices and cars can be similar.

  • US locations

    More locations means more choice of neighborhood and airport pickups and easier one-way returns.

  • Loyalty program

    A free loyalty program often lets you skip the counter line and earn free rental days.

  • Skip the counter

    Skipping the counter can save an hour at busy airports after a long flight.

  • Minimum renter age (years)

    Renters under 25 face higher fees and fewer car choices, and some companies won't rent to them at all.

  • Young renter fee ($/day)

    Young renter fees can add more per day than the car itself, so check the fee before comparing prices.

  • Additional driver fee

    Adding a second driver can cost $10–15 a day unless your spouse or loyalty status makes it free.

  • One way rentals

    One-way rentals let you fly home from a different city, but often carry a drop fee.

  • Cancellation policy

    Pay-later reservations are usually free to cancel; prepaid rates are cheaper but can cost you if plans change.

  • Mileage

    Mileage caps can make a long road trip expensive, so check before you book a cheap rate.

  • Debit cards accepted

    Without a credit card, some companies refuse the rental or hold a large deposit on your debit card.

  • Damage protection

    Your own car insurance or credit card may already cover rental damage, so you may not need to buy the waiver.

  • Roadside assistance

    Basic roadside help is usually included for car breakdowns, but lockouts, keys, and flat tires often cost extra.

  • Electric vehicles

    EVs can be cheaper to fuel, but you need to plan charging and check the return charge level rules.

  • Mobile app

    An app lets you manage the booking, skip the counter, and contact support during the rental.

About the services

  • Enterprise Rent-A-Car · Enterprise Mobility

    Large US network of neighborhood and airport branches, good for local, insurance-replacement and road-trip rentals. Unlimited mileage on most car classes and a $15/day extra-driver fee with spouses free. Enterprise Plus earns points but does not let you skip the counter.

  • National Car Rental · Enterprise Mobility

    Airport-focused brand aimed at frequent and business travelers. Free Emerald Club members can skip the counter and pick any car in the Emerald Aisle for the midsize rate, and members' family drive free. Fewer US locations (about 300) than Enterprise.

  • Alamo Rent A Car · Enterprise Mobility

    Leisure and vacation-focused airport brand. Anyone can Skip the Counter at select locations after online check-in (credit card required), and free Alamo Insiders get 5% off pay-later base rates. Pay Now bookings carry $50-$100 cancellation fees.

  • Hertz · The Hertz Corporation

    Major airport and neighborhood brand with a large EV fleet (Tesla, Polestar). Free Hertz Gold+ members skip the line at select locations and their spouse or partner drives free. Minimum age is 20 in most states, with a $25/day young renter fee.

  • Dollar Car Rental · The Hertz Corporation

    Hertz-owned budget brand at airports in popular leisure destinations. Rents from age 20 (18 in NY and MI) and offers unlimited mileage on most US rentals. Debit cards work only on smaller car classes, with a $500 hold.

  • Thrifty Car Rental · The Hertz Corporation

    A budget brand of Hertz for travelers who want low rates at major US airports. Anyone can check in online and go straight to the car at 60+ airports. Renters can be 20 in most states, but debit cards come with a $500 extra deposit and extra ID rules.

  • Avis · Avis Budget Group

    A full-service rental brand that suits business and frequent travelers who want to skip the counter with free Avis Preferred. Spouses and partners drive free; other extra drivers cost about $13 a day. Renters 21 to 24 pay a surcharge and cannot rent larger SUVs or luxury cars.

  • Budget Car Rental · Avis Budget Group

    Avis Budget Group's value brand, aimed at price-conscious leisure travelers, with 1,444 US locations. Free Fastbreak lets members skip the line. Renters under 25 pay about $27 a day and must use a credit card, not a debit card.

  • Payless Car Rental · Avis Budget Group

    A low-cost brand from Avis Budget Group with about 120 locations, mostly at major airports. It suits travelers chasing the lowest base rate. Some locations ask for proof of your own auto insurance, and there is no skip-the-counter program.

  • SIXT · Sixt SE

    A German rental company with a premium fleet (BMW, Mercedes, Audi) at hundreds of US airport and downtown branches. Free SIXT ONE gives member rates and app-based counter skipping. Debit cards need a return ticket or proof of address and are not accepted for luxury cars.

  • Fox Rent A Car · Europcar Mobility Group

    Low-cost car rental brand serving mostly US airports from off-airport lots reached by shuttle. Suits budget-minded leisure travelers; it has far fewer locations than the big brands, and debit-card renters need a return flight itinerary and a $500 deposit.

  • Turo · Turo Inc.

    Peer-to-peer marketplace where you book a specific car from a private host or small business, often with delivery to an airport or address. Suits renters who want a particular model or a lower minimum age; mileage limits, rules and fees vary by host, and one-way trips are not bookable.

  • Zipcar · Avis Budget Group

    Membership car sharing: book by the hour or day and unlock cars parked in reserved city and campus spots with the app. Gas, roughly 200 miles a day and basic coverage are included; it needs an approved membership (application fee plus plan), and cars must go back to their home spot.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons