Carpet and upholstery cleaners

Carpet and upholstery cleaners compared: full-size upright carpet cleaners from Bissell, Hoover, Shark and Rug Doctor, and portable spot cleaners for stains, stairs, sofas and car seats. The choice comes down to how much carpet you clean, how well a machine extracts water so carpets dry fast, tank sizes and refills, and how much effort it takes to use and clean afterward.

Last updated

How to choose

Upright or spot cleaner

  • Whole rooms and high-traffic areas: an upright with spinning brushes and a wide cleaning path does the job in a fraction of the time.
  • Pet accidents, spills, stairs, upholstery and cars: a portable spot cleaner is quicker to grab and easier to clean up. Many households own one of each.

Extraction and drying matter most

Carpet that stays wet for hours can smell musty or grow mildew. Machines with strong suction and a dry-only pass pull out more water; go slowly on the dry passes, open windows and run fans. Avoid over-wetting by using fewer wet passes and more dry passes.

Tanks and refills

Larger clean-water tanks mean fewer refills on big rooms, but full tanks add weight. Check the dirty tank is not much smaller than the clean tank, and that both are easy to carry, empty and rinse.

Cleaning up afterward

Rinse tanks, the brush area and hose after every use to prevent odors. Self-cleaning cycles, removable brush rolls and hose-rinse tools save time. Dried pet hair and debris left in the nozzle will smell later.

Formula and warranty

Some makers require their own formula to keep the warranty; others work with water only for light cleaning. Factor formula cost in, and test any formula on a hidden spot first, especially on wool and upholstery.

Check your carpet and fabric

Read the carpet or upholstery care label: some fabrics (marked S or X) should not be cleaned with water at all, and some carpet warranties require professional hot-water extraction at set intervals.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$129.99
$179.99
$249.99
$279.99
$399.95
$429
$199.99
$289.99
$174.99
$129.99
$597.99
$189.99
$299.99
$139.99
$699
⠿
Type
Portable spot cleaner
Portable spot cleaner
Portable spot cleaner
Upright with hose for stairs
Upright carpet cleaner
Upright with hose for stairs
Cordless spot cleaner
Upright with hose for stairs
Upright carpet cleaner
Portable spot cleaner
Upright carpet cleaner
Portable spot cleaner
Upright with hose for stairs
Portable spot cleaner
Upright carpet cleaner
⠿
Clean water tank
0.38 gal
0.5 gal
0.5 gal
1 gal
1 gal
1.75 gal
0.26 gal
1 gal
0.62 gal
0.31 gal
2 gal
0.75 gal
Not stated
Not stated
0.53 gal
⠿
Dirty water tank
Not stated
0.38 gal
0.4 gal
1 gal
1 gal
1.75 gal
0.29 gal
Not stated
Not stated
0.18 gal
3.5 gal
1.1 gal
Not stated
Not stated
0.45 gal
⠿
Cleaning path
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
11 in
11 in
10.5 in
Doesn't apply
12 in
7.5 in
Doesn't apply
Not stated
Doesn't apply
10 in
Doesn't apply
Not stated
⠿
Brush type
Tool brush only
Tool brush only
Tool brush only
Antimicrobial brush rolls
Two rotating brush rolls
8-row DirtLifter PowerBrush
Tool brush only
FlexForce PowerBrushes
PowerSpin pet brush roll
Tool brush only (2-in-1 bristle and rubber-nub insert)
Vibrating brush
Tool brush only (rubberized-bristle pet tool)
High-speed brushroll
Tool brush only (3.5-in reversible bristle tool)
Single brush roller
⠿
Heated cleaning
None
None
Steam (HydroSteam)
HeatWave keeps water warm
Steam (HydroSteam)
None
None
None; HeatForce warm air aids drying
None (HeatForce aids drying only)
None
None
None
None
None
HeatedWash keeps water warm
⠿
Drying
Not stated
Not stated
Upholstery dries in about 30 minutes
Dry in about 30 minutes in Express Cleaning Mode
Dries in about 30 minutes in Quick Dry Mode
Cleans on forward and back pass; dries faster than rental cleaners (maker claim)
Not stated
Auto-dry on the pull-back stroke with HeatForce; Dry Only mode
HeatForce dries as you clean
Not stated
No dry mode; strong suction said to speed drying
Not stated
Quick Dry Mode; PowerSpray avoids oversoaking
Not stated
167°F heated PowerDry
⠿
Extraction power
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
TurboStrength motor; 40% stronger suction (maker claim)
Not stated
12 amp motor
165W motor
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Industrial-grade vacuum motor (no figure published)
2x the suction of Shark StainStriker (ASTM F558 peak air watts, maker claim)
960 W motor
450 W motor
130 W suction
⠿
Hose and tools
HydroRinse self-cleaning hose tool, 3-in tough stain tool
Crevice tool, pet hair removal tool, self-cleaning tough stain tool
5-in tough stain tool, multi-surface tool for tile and grout
8 ft hose, 3-in tough stain tool, 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool
2-in-1 pet upholstery tool, 6-in tough stain tool
9 ft hose, 6-in tough stain tool
4 ft hose, 4 in tough stain tool, self-cleaning hose
8 ft hose, 2-in-1 pet tool, stair tool, storage bag
8 ft hose, 2-in-1 pet tool
4.5 ft hose, 7-in WidePath tool, TightSpot tool, hose rinse tool
No hose included; upholstery tool sold separately
Hose with handheld dual-action pet tool
Built-in pull-out spot tool, 3.5-in reversible bristle tool, 7-in wide path tool, crevice tool
4.3 ft hose, 3.5-in reversible bristle tool, 7-in wide path tool, crevice tool
Accessory hose with stain-remover tool
⠿
Self cleaning
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Weight
9.65 lb
11 lb
13 lb
18.9 lb
22.5 lb
42 lb
7.2 lb
18.5 lb
18.4 lb
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
22.71 lb
13.23 lb
21.83 lb
⠿
Cord length
15 ft
15 ft
15 ft
25 ft
25 ft
25 ft
0 ft
22 ft
20 ft
15 ft
Not stated
Not stated
20 ft
12 ft
Not stated
⠿
Formula required
Trial formula included
Add BISSELL portable cleaner formula to the solution line
PET PRO OXY formula included
Use BISSELL 2X upright carpet-cleaning formula; formula amount varies by mode
Use BISSELL upright carpet-cleaning formula
Trial formula included
Use portable cleaner formulas, such as BISSELL Spot & Stain or Pet Pro Oxy Spot Cleaner
Auto Mix dispenses Hoover solution; sample included
Sample Hoover solution included; Hoover formulas recommended
Trial Oxy solution included; Hoover Oxy formula recommended
48 oz Oxy formula included; no requirement stated
Trial solution included; Rug Doctor pet formula recommended
Uses two Shark formulas (StainStriker OXY + Deep Clean Pro); trial bottles included
Uses two Shark formulas mixed in the tool; trial bottles included
Use Tineco solution only
⠿
Pet features
Pet Proven certified
Pet hair removal tool; works with PET PRO OXY urine eliminator formula
PET PRO OXY urine eliminator formula included
2-in-1 pet upholstery tool; CleanShot OXY pretreater
2-in-1 pet upholstery tool for wet and dry messes
Pet Proven certified; 6 in tough stain tool
Pet Proven certified; included PRO OXY formula targets pet messes; HydroRinse self-cleaning hose
2-in-1 pet tool
Antimicrobial PowerSpin pet brush roll; Paws & Claws formula sample
Rubber-nub insert for pet messes
Not stated
Dual-action pet tool picks up pet hair
Removes pet urine odors with Shark formula
Pet urine odor removal with Shark formula
Not stated
⠿
Warranty
1 year
3 years
3 years
5 years
5 years
5 years
2 years
5 years (motor)
2 years
2 years
1 year
1 year
5 years
3 years
2 years

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Spot cleaners cost $80 to $200; full-size uprights $150 to $500; one rental can cost $40 to $60 a day.

  • Type

    Uprights clean whole rooms fast; portable spot cleaners handle stains, stairs, upholstery and car seats.

  • Clean water tank (gal)

    Bigger tanks mean fewer trips to the sink when cleaning large rooms.

  • Dirty water tank (gal)

    A dirty tank smaller than the clean tank means emptying before you run out of clean water.

  • Cleaning path (in)

    Wider paths clean a room in fewer passes.

  • Brush type

    Spinning brushes lift ground-in dirt and pet hair from deep pile; spot cleaners rely on scrubbing tools.

  • Heated cleaning

    Warm water dissolves greasy soil better; most home machines only maintain the temperature of hot tap water.

  • Drying

    Faster drying means you can walk on carpets sooner and reduces mildew risk.

  • Extraction power

    Stronger extraction pulls more water out, which means cleaner, drier carpet.

  • Hose and tools

    A hose and upholstery tool let an upright clean stairs, sofas and car seats too.

  • Self cleaning

    Flushing the hose and nozzle after use prevents odors and clogs.

  • Weight (lb)

    Full tanks add 10 lb or more; lighter machines are easier on stairs.

  • Cord length (ft)

    A long cord reaches across large rooms without changing outlets.

  • Formula required

    Brand formulas add ongoing cost; some warranties require them.

  • Pet features

    Pet owners need tools that tackle urine stains and hair without clogging.

  • Warranty

    Pumps and motors are the usual failures; a longer warranty is worth having on a pricier machine.

About the products

  • Little Green Multi-Purpose Portable Carpet Cleaner 1400B · BISSELL

    The classic corded Little Green for spot stains, stairs, upholstery and car seats, with a 48 oz clean tank and a HydroRinse tool to flush the hose. No heater, and it is too small for whole rooms.

  • Little Green Pet Pro Portable Carpet Cleaner 3909 · BISSELL

    The current Pro tier of the Little Green line, with bigger tanks than the basic model plus a pet hair tool, crevice tool and self-cleaning stain tool. Corded, unheated, and heavier to carry than the 1400B.

  • Little Green HydroSteam Pet Portable Carpet Cleaner 3605 · BISSELL

    A portable spot cleaner that adds steam for greasy, set-in stains and can also clean tile grout and sneakers. Upholstery dries in about 30 minutes, but at 13 lb it is one of the heavier portables.

  • ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Upright Carpet Cleaner 3588 · BISSELL

    A full-size upright for whole rooms, with a 1-gallon tank, 8 ft hose with pet upholstery tool, and an Express mode that dries in about 30 minutes. Brush rolls and dirty tank are antimicrobial to curb odors.

  • Revolution HydroSteam Pet Upright Carpet Cleaner 3432 · BISSELL

    An upright that adds steam (Steam Pretreat and SteamWash modes) for sticky, stuck-on messes, plus a Quick Dry mode of about 30 minutes. It costs well more than non-steam uprights.

  • Big Green Clean Machine Professional Carpet Cleaner 86T3 · BISSELL

    A rental-style upright with 1.75-gallon tanks and an 8-row DirtLifter brush for large or heavily soiled carpet, plus a 9 ft hose for stairs. It is big and heavy, and there is no heater.

  • Little Green Cordless Portable Carpet Cleaner 3682 · BISSELL

    A battery-powered Little Green for spills away from outlets, like cars, RVs and patio furniture, with a 165W motor and up to 35 minutes of run time. Tanks are small, so it suits spots rather than rugs.

  • SmartWash+ Automatic Carpet Cleaner (FH52000V) · Hoover

    A full-size upright that sprays as you push and dries as you pull, with no trigger and automatic solution mixing, plus an 8 ft hose for stairs. Easy for occasional whole-room cleaning; Hoover's own store showed it as 'Returning Soon' (out of stock) in October 2026.

  • PowerDash Pet Advanced Compact Carpet Cleaner (FH55000V) · Hoover

    A light, compact upright for apartments and high-traffic patches, with a PowerSpin pet brush roll, HeatForce drying and a hose for stairs and upholstery. Small tanks mean frequent refills on larger rooms.

  • CleanSlate Pet Spot Cleaner (FH14000V) · Hoover

    An inexpensive corded portable spot cleaner for spills, pet accidents, stairs and car seats, with a 7-inch wide tool, a tight-spot tool and a hose rinse port. Its 40 oz clean tank suits spot jobs, not whole rooms.

  • Mighty Pro X3 Carpet Cleaner (90010) · Rug Doctor

    The same heavy, commercial-grade machine Rug Doctor rents in stores, sold for home use, with big tanks and a vibrating brush for deep one-pass cleaning. It is heavy and pricey, and the upholstery tool is sold separately.

  • Rug Doctor Pet Portable Spot Cleaner (93390) · Rug Doctor

    A wheeled portable spot cleaner with a retractable handle and a dual-action pet tool whose rubber bristles pull up hair while extracting stains. Strong suction for its class, but it costs more than most spot cleaners.

  • CarpetXpert with StainStriker Upright Deep Carpet Cleaner (EX201) · Shark

    An upright carpet cleaner with a built-in pull-out StainStriker spot tool that mixes two Shark formulas on contact for tough stains. Users report small tanks that need frequent refills, and it relies on Shark's two formulas.

  • StainStriker Portable Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner (PX201) · Shark

    A portable spot cleaner that combines two Shark formulas inside the tool for stains and odors on carpets, couches and car seats. Ongoing cost of two proprietary formulas; a shorter 4.3 ft hose than some rivals.

  • CARPET ONE Cruiser Smart Carpet Cleaner · Tineco

    A premium smart upright with dirt-sensing suction, self-propelled push assist, heated PowerDry drying and a self-cleaning brush cycle. Expensive, with small tanks for whole-house jobs, and Tineco says to use only its own solution.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons