Luggage

Wheeled suitcases from the brands US travelers shop most, from direct-to-consumer hardside carry-ons to lifetime-guaranteed softside workhorses and aluminum-era icons. The real trade-offs are size versus airline limits, weight versus toughness, and how much a warranty actually covers when an airline breaks a wheel.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with the trips you take

Decide whether you need a carry-on (no bag fee, no waiting at the carousel, but tight space and strict size limits) or a checked case (a week or more of clothes, but a bag fee on most fares). Many people buy a carry-on first and add a medium checked case from the same line later; several of these nest inside each other for storage.

Check the size against your airline, including wheels

  • The common US domestic limit is 22 x 14 x 9 in including wheels and handles. Compare the Height, Width and Depth rows to it: several popular "carry-ons" here are deeper or wider than that and rely on agents not measuring.
  • International and budget airlines are often smaller (around 55 x 40 x 20 cm) and many cap carry-on weight at 7 to 10 kg, which makes the case's own weight matter.
  • Expanding a carry-on almost always takes it past the limit; treat expansion as room for the trip home in a checked bag, or for compressing back down.

Hardside or softside

  • Hardside (polycarbonate, polypropylene, aluminum) protects fragile things and sheds rain. Polycarbonate flexes and pops back; polypropylene is lighter and cheaper; shells scuff and can crack.
  • Softside (ballistic or ripstop nylon) squeezes into tight bins, usually has outside pockets, and abrasion shows less. Ballistic nylon is the toughest; ultralight ripstop saves weight.

Wheels and handle

Four- or eight-wheel spinners glide upright through terminals and down aircraft aisles. Two inline wheels roll better over curbs and cobblestones, are harder to break, and leave more packing room inside.

Read the warranty, not the word "lifetime"

Most "lifetime" warranties cover manufacturing defects only. A few also cover airline or accidental damage, which is how most suitcases actually die. Check whether repairs are free, whether you pay shipping, and whether you need proof of purchase.

Use the trial

Several direct-to-consumer brands let you return a case within 100 days, but most require it to be unused. Pack it at home, measure it against your airline's limits, and roll it around before the first trip.

Before you buy

  • Prices here are regular list prices; luggage is on sale often, so it pays to wait for a promotion.
  • Compare capacity in liters rather than inches, and check whether the maker quotes interior or exterior volume.
  • Extras like ejectable batteries and front laptop pockets add weight; pick them only if you will use them.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$275
$219.99
$279.99
$390
$450
$729
$990
$1,150
$295
$268
$349.99
$328
$398
$300
⠿
Size class
Carry-on
Carry-on
Large checked
Carry-on
Medium checked
Carry-on
Carry-on
Medium checked
Carry-on
Carry-on
Carry-on
Carry-on
Medium checked
Carry-on
⠿
Shell type
Hardside
Hardside
Hardside
Softside
Softside
Softside
Hardside
Hardside
Hardside
Hardside
Softside
Hardside
Hardside
Softside
⠿
Shell material
Polycarbonate
Polypropylene
Polypropylene
Nylon with DuraGuard coating
Nylon with DuraGuard coating
Ballistic nylon
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate
Recycled polyester fabric
Polycarbonate
Polycarbonate
Recycled nylon ripstop on aluminum frame
⠿
Height
22 in
21.25 in
31.1 in
23.5 in
28 in
22 in
21.7 in
26.4 in
21.5 in
22.83 in
22.75 in
22.1 in
26 in
21.7 in
⠿
Width
14 in
15.25 in
20.95 in
14.5 in
18.5 in
14 in
15.8 in
17.8 in
15 in
15.7 in
15 in
14.5 in
18.5 in
13.8 in
⠿
Depth
9 in
10 in
13.8 in
9 in
11.75 in
9 in
9.1 in
9.5 in
8.5 in
10 in
10 in
9.1 in
10.8 in
9.1 in
⠿
Weight
6.6 lb
6.5 lb
9.59 lb
7.8 lb
9.8 lb
10 lb
7.1 lb
9 lb
7.4 lb
7.81 lb
7 lb
8.6 lb
11.2 lb
4.63 lb
⠿
Capacity
39.9 L
Not stated
Not stated
46 L
97 L
37 L, 48 L expanded
36 L
60 L
42 L
49 L, 61 L expanded
42 L, 47 L expanded
41 L
72 L
40 L
⠿
Expandable
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
⠿
Wheels
4 spinner
8 spinner
8 spinner
4 spinner
4 spinner
4 spinner
8 spinner
8 spinner
4 spinner
4 spinner
8 spinner
4 spinner
4 spinner
2 inline
⠿
Built in TSA lock
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
⠿
Front laptop pocket
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Compression system
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
⠿
Warranty
Limited lifetime
10 years, limited
10 years, limited
Limited lifetime, defects only
Limited lifetime, defects only
Lifetime, covers airline damage
Lifetime guarantee
Lifetime guarantee
Lifetime, manufacturing faults
Limited lifetime
10 years
Lifetime repair; 5 years free, covers rough travel
Lifetime repair; 5 years free, covers rough travel
Lifetime repair or replace, any damage
⠿
Trial period
100 days
60 days
60 days
100 days
100 days
30 days
30 days
30 days
100 days
45 days
100 days
100 days
100 days
Not stated

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Luggage prices span 10x; a premium case buys better wheels, materials and warranty, but a mid-price case does the same job for occasional travelers.

  • Size class

    Carry-ons avoid bag fees and waiting at the carousel; checked sizes hold a week or more of clothes but cost a bag fee on most fares.

  • Shell type

    Hardside protects fragile items and sheds rain; softside flexes into tight bins, usually has outside pockets, and scuffs less visibly.

  • Shell material

    Polycarbonate flexes and recovers from impacts; aluminum is toughest but dents and is heavy; ballistic nylon resists abrasion and is easy to repair.

  • Height (in)

    US airlines' common carry-on limit is 22 in tall including wheels; a case over that can be gate-checked.

  • Width (in)

    Most US carry-on limits allow 14 in wide; wider cases may not fit sideways in bins.

  • Depth (in)

    Most US carry-on limits allow 9 in deep; expanding a carry-on usually pushes it past that.

  • Weight (lb)

    Every pound of case is a pound less packing under airline weight limits (often 50 lb checked, and strict carry-on limits on many non-US airlines).

  • Capacity (L)

    Liters compare packing space across brands better than inches; a carry-on is typically 35 to 45 L.

  • Expandable

    Expansion gives room for souvenirs on the way home, but an expanded carry-on may exceed size limits.

  • Wheels

    Spinners glide upright through airports and aisles; 2 inline wheels roll better over curbs and cobblestones and waste less interior space.

  • Built in TSA lock

    A built-in TSA lock secures the zips without a padlock that security can still open; matters most for checked bags.

  • Front laptop pocket

    A front pocket lets you pull out a laptop at security without opening the case; useful for business travel.

  • Compression system

    Compression lets you pack more and keeps clothes from shifting; tie-down straps alone do much less.

  • Warranty

    A warranty that covers airline damage saves the cost of a new case after one bad baggage handler; many cover only manufacturing defects.

  • Trial period (days)

    A long trial lets you test the case on a real trip before committing.

About the products

  • Monos Carry-On · Monos

    A light (6.6 lb) polycarbonate carry-on that fits the 22 x 14 x 9 in US limit exactly, with a removable compression pad. Not expandable and no outside pockets; often discounted from its list price.

  • Freeform Carry-On Spinner · Samsonite

    An affordable, light polypropylene hardside carry-on that expands and has double spinner wheels. Its 10 in depth is over the common US 9 in limit, and Samsonite's own store blocked research, so details come from retailers.

  • Freeform Large Spinner · Samsonite

    A large, inexpensive polypropylene checked case for long trips or families, expandable with double spinner wheels and a 10-year limited warranty. Large cases like this can easily exceed 50 lb when full.

  • Platinum Elite Carry-On Expandable Spinner · Travelpro

    A softside nylon carry-on built for frequent flyers, with a fold-out suiter, USB port and 2 in expansion. Travelpro lists it at 23.5 in tall including handles, over the 22 in US limit; the warranty covers defects only.

  • Platinum Elite Medium Check-In Expandable Spinner · Travelpro

    Travelpro's medium softside checked case with a built-in suiter, TSA lock and 2 in expansion, sized to the 62 linear inch checked limit. Defects-only lifetime warranty plus a 100-day trial.

  • Baseline Essential 22" Carry-On Expandable Spinner · Briggs & Riley

    A premium ballistic-nylon carry-on whose CX system expands for packing, then compresses back to 22 x 14 x 9 in. Heavy at 10 lb, but Briggs & Riley repairs it for life even after airline damage, with no proof of purchase.

  • Rimowa Essential Cabin · Rimowa

    Rimowa's polycarbonate cabin case with Multiwheel double wheels, a Flex Divider compression system and a lifetime guarantee. Expensive, and at 15.8 in wide it is better suited to international cabin limits than tight US bins.

  • Rimowa Essential Check-In M · Rimowa

    Rimowa's medium polycarbonate checked case (60 L) with Multiwheel wheels, TSA locks and the Flex Divider. A luxury price for a case that is light for its size; returns must be unused within 30 days.

  • July Carry On · July

    A polycarbonate carry-on with an ejectable USB-C battery, Y-strap compression and an integrated TSA lock, sized slightly under US limits at 21.5 x 15 x 8.5 in. Lifetime warranty covers manufacturing faults.

  • BÉIS The Carry-On Roller · BÉIS

    A big-capacity polycarbonate carry-on (49 L, 61 L expanded) with a built-in weight indicator and compression. At 22.83 x 15.7 x 10 in it is larger than most US carry-on limits, so it suits overpackers who accept gate-check risk.

  • Chatelet Air 2.0 23-Inch Expandable Carry-On · Delsey

    A vintage-styled softside carry-on in recycled polyester with leather-look trim, double wheels, a SECURITECH double zipper and expansion. Larger than US carry-on limits at 22.75 x 15 x 10 in; often on sale well below list.

  • Away The Carry-On 3 · Away

    Away's current polycarbonate carry-on with a compression pad, wheel brakes and an embedded TSA lock. Not expandable (that is the Flex version), and at 22.1 x 14.4 in it is a touch over the 22 x 14 in US limit.

  • Away The Medium 3 · Away

    Away's mid-size checked case for one- to two-week trips, with the same compression pad, brakes and lock as the carry-on. Repairs are free for five years; after that Away still repairs but may charge.

  • Ozone 2-Wheel 40L Carry-On · Osprey

    An ultralight (4.6 lb) softside carry-on on two large inline wheels, made from recycled ripstop on an aluminum frame. Osprey repairs or replaces it for any damage; no expansion, lock or compression panel.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons