Nanny payroll services

Nanny payroll services run your caregiver's paychecks and handle the household employer taxes that come with them: tax account registration, withholding, quarterly filings, and year-end W-2 and Schedule H forms. They differ mostly in monthly price, what year-end work costs extra, and how much human help you get.

Last updated

How to choose

If you pay a nanny or other household worker more than the IRS threshold in a year, you are a household employer with real tax duties. A payroll service takes over the calculating, filing and depositing; you still owe the taxes themselves.

Start with what you need

  • Hands-off or hands-on. Some plans only run payroll and file for you; others add a dedicated specialist who handles agency notices.
  • One caregiver or several. Check what each extra employee costs, and whether the service supports multi-state or multi-worksite situations.
  • Your state. Pay frequency rules and state registrations vary, and some states charge their own registration fee.

Compare the full yearly cost

The monthly fee is only part of it. Add any setup fee, the year-end forms fee, and extra-employee fees, and check what you pay if you cancel mid-year (several services still bill to file the quarter or year in progress).

Check the details

  • Does the service prepare Schedule H and W-2s, or charge extra?
  • Will it deal with the IRS and your state if they send a notice?
  • Is there a contract, a free first month, or a guarantee against filing penalties?

Fees and promotions change often, so confirm current prices on the provider's site before you sign up.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide services and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the company doesn't publish it

FeatureService ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Monthly price
$59/month
$49/month
$59/month
$45/month
⠿
Highest plan price
$75/month
$49/month
$155/month
$45/month
⠿
Plans offered
2 plans: Essentials and Plus
1 plan
3 plans: Guided, Complete, Premier
1 plan
⠿
Setup fee
$0
$0
$120
$0
⠿
Year end filing fee
$100
$0
$130
from $50
⠿
Extra employee fee
$22/month
$10/month
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Free trial
First month free on Plus plan
Rest of sign-up month free
Free consultation; no free period listed
6 months free promotion
⠿
Cancel anytime
Not stated
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Direct deposit
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Files tax returns
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Schedule H prepared
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Tax account registration
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Tax agency notice help
Plus plan only
Included; may ask you to join calls
Included; IRS notice resolution
Not stated
⠿
Employee time tracking
Employee app, Plus plan only
Included (beta)
Online and mobile entry on all plans
Not stated
⠿
Dedicated account manager
Yes
No
Yes
No
⠿
Support channels
Phone, chat, email; Mon-Fri weekday hours
Phone and email; 98% of calls answered in 15 seconds
Phone and email; Mon-Fri 8:30 am-7 pm ET
Phone, Mon-Fri
⠿
Accuracy guarantee
Filing accuracy guarantee; 6-month refund guarantee
Not stated
Not stated
No-penalty tax filing guarantee

Why these features matter

  • Monthly price ($/month)

    The headline cost, but year-end and setup fees can add a lot to it.

  • Highest plan price ($/month)

    Shows what full-service support costs if you want a dedicated specialist.

  • Plans offered

    One plan is simpler; tiers let you pay for more help only if you need it.

  • Setup fee ($)

    An upfront cost that is easy to miss when comparing monthly prices.

  • Year end filing fee ($)

    Can add $50 to $130 a year on top of the monthly fee.

  • Extra employee fee ($/month)

    Matters if you also employ a housekeeper or a second caregiver.

  • Free trial

    Lets you test the service before paying.

  • Cancel anytime

    Nanny jobs end; you do not want to be locked into a contract.

  • Direct deposit

    Saves writing checks and gives a clear pay record.

  • Files tax returns

    The main reason to use a service rather than doing it yourself.

  • Schedule H prepared

    Schedule H goes with your personal tax return; having it ready simplifies tax time.

  • Tax account registration

    Registration is the confusing first step of hiring legally.

  • Tax agency notice help

    A tax notice is stressful; some services handle it, others leave you to it.

  • Employee time tracking

    Hours logged by your nanny cut errors and disputes on pay day.

  • Dedicated account manager

    Helps with complex situations like multiple states or back filings.

  • Support channels

    Payroll questions often come at deadlines.

  • Accuracy guarantee

    Shows who pays if a filing mistake causes a penalty.

About the services

  • HomePay · Care.com

    Household payroll and tax service run by Breedlove & Associates, a Care.com company. Two plans: Essentials for payroll and tax compliance, and Plus, which adds a dedicated account manager, tax notice handling and an employee app. Pricier than Poppins or SurePayroll, with a 6-month happiness guarantee.

  • Poppins Payroll · Poppins Payroll

    Household payroll only, on one flat plan with no setup fee, contract or year-end forms fee. Suits families who want a simple, low-cost service with phone support; extra employees are cheap. Fees apply if you close an account before quarter or year end.

  • HomeWork Solutions · Homework Solutions

    Household payroll and compliance specialist since 1993, with three tiers from self-service Guided to white-glove Premier. Strong on complex cases (multi-state, back filings, IRS notices), but a setup fee and annual year-end fee make it the costliest to start.

  • SurePayroll Household · SurePayroll (a Paychex company)

    Paychex-owned service (it absorbed NannyChex) with one household plan, a mobile app and automatic tax filing. Lowest list price here and a long free-month promotion, but year-end forms cost extra and phone support is weekday only.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons