Payroll services

US payroll services for small and midsize businesses compared at their entry full-service plans: online payroll apps, the big payroll processors, and PEOs. All of them pay employees and file payroll taxes; the differences are price structure, which states and forms are included, how fast direct deposit lands, contractor and benefits support, and the extra fees that show up after you sign.

Last updated

How to choose

Work out your real monthly cost

Most providers charge a base fee plus a fee per employee. Multiply out for your headcount, then add what you will actually use: extra states, off-cycle runs, year-end forms, time tracking and workers comp. Quote-only providers can be competitive for larger teams, but ask for every fee in writing.

Check states and filings

  • If anyone works remotely in another state, confirm the plan files there and whether each extra state costs more.
  • Full-service payroll should calculate, pay and file federal, state and local taxes and file W-2s and 1099s. Some budget plans leave state filing to you in certain states.
  • A tax penalty guarantee means the provider pays penalties caused by its own mistakes; it does not cover late or wrong data you provide.

Match the plan to your team

  • Only contractors: a contractor-only plan is far cheaper; check international contractor payments if you need them.
  • Hourly staff: built-in time tracking avoids re-keying hours.
  • Want benefits: providers with their own benefits brokerage, or a PEO, can offer health plans and 401(k)s that are hard for a small company to get alone.

PEO or payroll service

A PEO becomes your co-employer, which can unlock larger-company health insurance rates and handles HR compliance, but it costs more per employee and you share some control. A payroll service leaves you as sole employer at lower cost.

Before you switch

Switching mid-year means moving year-to-date totals; many providers do it free, others charge. Start at the beginning of a quarter if you can, run a parallel payroll first, and check how support handles urgent payday problems.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide services and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the company doesn't publish it

FeatureService ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
ADP
Links
⠿
ADP
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Price
$49/month
$50/month
$49/month
Not stated
$35/month
$37/month
Not stated
$39/month
Not stated
$29/month
$99/month
Not stated
$50/month
$40/month
$49/month
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Plan
Simple
Workforce Payroll
Payroll Essentials
Rippling Payroll (custom quote)
Full-service payroll
Full Service Payroll
Essential Payroll
Roll (single plan)
Basic
Full Service
Basic
Express
Payroll (non-PEO)
Wave Payroll
Payroll add-on (works with free Basic plan)
Deel Payroll: US (self-service)
TriNet PEO
Payroll Core
⠿
Per employee fee
$6
$7
$6
$10
$6
$5
Not stated
$5
Not stated
$7
$5
Not stated
$8
$6
$6
$29
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Quote only pricing
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Contractor only option
None (contractor-only plan closed to new sign-ups Oct 1, 2026)
Contractor Payments: $25/mo incl. 20 contractors + $2 per additional
None separate; contractors billed at $6 each on the same plan
Not stated
$6/mo per contractor paid, no base fee
Basic Payroll: $17/mo + $4 per worker; supports contractor-only runs.
Not stated
Same plan: $39/mo + $5 per worker
Not stated
No separate plan; contractors paid on Full Service
Not stated
Not stated
$8 per US contractor per month, only in months paid
$40/mo + $6 per contractor paid (same plan)
Not stated
$49 per contractor per month
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
All 50 states
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Multi state fees
Not on Simple; multi-state needs Plus ($80/mo); state registration add-on priced by state
Extra fee may apply (amount not published)
Included
Included
Included
$12/mo per additional state on Full Service; Basic has no filing service.
Multi-jurisdiction payroll included
Included
Included with tax service
$9.99/mo for multi-state; extra fee for local taxes
Additional state and local tax authorities included
Not stated
Included (you register in each state)
Same price in all states
Included (no state fees listed)
State registration help included
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Automatic tax filing
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Year end forms
W-2 and 1099 filed
W-2s for employees; 1099-NEC/MISC e-filed; mailed copies cost extra
W-2 and 1099 included; mailing by OnPay $10/form
W-2 and 1099 filed
W-2 and 1099 delivered digitally; $3 per mailed form
W-2 and 1099 filed
W-2 and 1099 created, delivered and e-filed (additional fee)
W-2 and 1099-NEC filed; delivered in app
W-2 and 1099 processing included
W-2 and 1099-NEC filed; $50 base + $5 per form yearly
W-2 and 1099 processing
W-2s and 1099-MISC prepared and delivered
W-2 and 1099 filings
W-2/W-3 filed; 1099-NEC generated but not filed
W-2s and 1099s included
W-2 filed and distributed
W-2 preparation and delivery
W-2s and Forms 940/941 handled
⠿
Tax penalty guarantee
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Unlimited payroll runs
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Fastest direct deposit
2 day (new employers start on 4 day; next day is an add-on)
Next day
2 day (2 or 4 day after risk review)
Not stated
Next day
2 day (for qualifying customers; otherwise 4 day)
Next day (eligible businesses)
Next day (same day for a per-transaction fee)
Not stated
2 day
Not stated
Not stated
4 day
3 day
Next day (2-day for qualified companies also listed)
2 to 3 days
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Contractor payments
Included (US); global contractors add-on
Included (US), billed at $7 per contractor
Included (US), billed per contractor paid
Included plus international contractors (global add-on)
Included (US)
Included (US)
Included (1099 contractors)
Included
Included
Included
Included
Included
Add-on: $8/US contractor, $39/international contractor per month
Included ($6 per contractor paid)
Included (1099s)
Add-on: global contractors $49/contractor/mo
Included
Included
⠿
Benefits administration
Health benefits via own brokerage; 401(k) integrations
Health packages (Allstate) and 401(k) (Vestwell) via partners
Integrated health and 401(k); pay only plan premiums
Add-on (Rippling Benefits)
Health insurance and 401(k) add-ons
Free health-benefit integration via SimplyInsured; shop plans or connect an existing plan.
Health insurance and ADP 401(k) as add-ons
Deductions for outside benefit and retirement plans only
Health insurance and 401(k) as add-ons
Health insurance via Paychex Insurance Agency; 401(k) add-on
Benefits admin add-on
Separate Benefits Management module
Health insurance add-on $8/benefits-eligible employee/mo; 401(k)
None
401(k) and health benefit integrations
Benefits Management add-on $10/employee/mo; own broker or partners
PEO health, dental, vision and TriNet-sponsored 401(k)
Benefits administration add-on
⠿
Workers comp
Pay-as-you-go via partner (NEXT), from $14/mo
Pay-as-you-go via partner (NEXT)
Pay-as-you-go via partner
Not stated
Pay-as-you-go add-on
Pay-as-you-go insurance through ERGO NEXT Insurance.
Pay-as-you-go add-on
Referral to ADP insurance agency
Pay-as-you-go add-on
Quotes via SureProtect partner; not in ND, OH, WA, WY
Pay-as-you-go add-on
Not stated
Access to workers' comp
None
Via integration
Not stated
Included administration via PEO
Workers comp tracking included
⠿
Time tracking
Add-on, $6/mo per person
None (Premium and Elite only)
Add-on, $15/mo + $4/worker
Add-on (Time & Attendance)
Included (timecard import from Square POS and Team app)
Add-on, from $6/mo + $2/worker
Add-on
Included
Add-on
Add-on timeclock integration from $5/mo + $3 per employee
Add-on (Time + Scheduling)
Not in Express; included from Enrich tier
Basic timecards included; Time Tracking add-on $8/employee/mo
None (leave tracking only)
Included (Homebase time clock and timesheets)
Included
Time and attendance available
Add-on (Time and Labor Management)
⠿
Setup fee
None
None published
None (free setup and data migration)
Quote-based; implementation manager guides setup
None
None
Quote-based
None
Not stated
None
None
Quote-based
None
None
None
None published
Quote-based
One-time implementation fee (quote-based)
⠿
Extra fees
Next-day pay $15/mo + $3/person; same-day pay $90/payroll; state tax registration varies by state
Background checks from $29.99; print-and-mail 1099 copies extra
Mailed year-end forms $10/form; no fees for extra states or off-cycle runs
Not stated
$3 per mailed year-end form; paid amendment services
Basic: 1099 e-file $20 for first 5, then $2 each (max $80); Full Service included.
W-2/1099 forms extra; other fees by quote
Same-day direct deposit per-transaction fee
Not stated
Year-end forms $50 + $5/form; multi-state $9.99/mo; local tax fee
$59 payroll setup fee
Not stated
Per-person add-ons: contractors, health insurance, time tracking
None published
None published
Add-ons: benefits $10, expenses from $8 per employee/mo
Background checks, drug screening, premium training extra
Not stated
⠿
Phone support
Phone and chat during business hours
Phone and chat
Mon-Fri 9am-8pm ET
Email and live chat (no phone line stated)
Mon-Fri 6am-6pm PT
877-968-7147, Mon–Fri, 9 a.m.–7 p.m. ET.
24/7 phone and chat
24/7 live chat; phone Mon-Fri 8am-5pm EST
Online chat only; phone support is an add-on
Mon-Fri 8am-7pm CT
Mon-Fri 8am-8pm ET for payroll
Email, live chat or phone (hours not published)
Phone, email and chat (24/7 support only on PEO plans)
Email and chat only (chat Mon-Fri)
Live human support 7am-7pm CT, every day
24/7 chat; phone for largest clients only
Phone and online HR support
Dedicated specialist
⠿
PEO
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
No

Why these features matter

  • Price ($/month)

    The fixed part of the cost; it matters most for very small teams.

  • Plan

    Features and fees differ by plan; this is the plan the rest of the column describes.

  • Per employee fee ($)

    The part that grows with headcount; at 20+ people it usually outweighs the base fee.

  • Quote only pricing

    Quote-only pricing makes comparison harder and often includes setup and add-on fees you must ask about.

  • Contractor only option

    Businesses with only contractors can pay much less on a contractor-only plan.

  • All 50 states

    If you hire remote staff in other states, the provider must register and file in each one.

  • Multi state fees

    Per-state fees add up quickly for remote teams.

  • Automatic tax filing

    Automatic filing is the core value of full-service payroll: it prevents missed deadlines and penalties.

  • Year end forms

    Some providers charge extra per W-2 or 1099, a surprise cost every January.

  • Tax penalty guarantee

    A guarantee shifts the risk of a filing mistake to the provider.

  • Unlimited payroll runs

    Bonuses, corrections and final paychecks need extra runs; per-run fees punish them.

  • Fastest direct deposit

    Faster deposit lets you run payroll later and handle last-minute changes.

  • Contractor payments

    Most small businesses pay at least some contractors; international contractor payments are a plus for remote teams.

  • Benefits administration

    Offering health and retirement benefits helps hiring, and handling them in payroll avoids double entry.

  • Workers comp

    Pay-as-you-go workers comp avoids large up-front premiums and year-end audits.

  • Time tracking

    Built-in time tracking feeds hours straight into payroll for hourly staff.

  • Setup fee

    Setup fees and paid onboarding can equal a few months of service.

  • Extra fees

    The headline price rarely includes everything; compare the fees you will actually trigger.

  • Phone support

    Payroll problems are urgent on payday; reachable phone support matters.

  • PEO

    A PEO becomes co-employer and can offer big-company benefits, but costs more and takes over some HR control.

About the services

  • Gusto · Gusto

    Full-service payroll with built-in benefits brokerage and many add-ons, popular with small teams. The entry Simple plan covers one state only and charges extra for next-day pay and time tracking.

  • QuickBooks Workforce Payroll · Intuit

    Intuit's payroll (now sold as QuickBooks Workforce) suits businesses already on QuickBooks accounting, with next-day deposit on the entry plan. Time tracking and the tax penalty protection come only on higher tiers, and launch prices are promotional.

  • OnPay · OnPay

    One flat-priced payroll plan with all 50 states, unlimited runs and free migration included, a good fit for cost-conscious small businesses. Direct deposit is 2 or 4 days depending on a risk review, and HR and time tracking are paid add-ons.

  • Rippling Payroll · Rippling

    Payroll built into Rippling's wider HR, IT and finance platform, strong for growing or multi-state teams that want global contractor and employee pay in one system. Pricing is quote-only and depends on the modules you buy.

  • Square Payroll · Square

    Low-cost full-service payroll that imports timecards and tips from Square POS, well suited to restaurants and shops already using Square. A cheaper contractor-only plan exists, and benefits and workers' comp are add-ons.

  • Patriot Software Payroll · Patriot Software

    Budget payroll from a US-based provider with free setup and support, aimed at very small businesses. Its Full Service plan files taxes for you; time tracking and HR are low-cost add-ons.

  • RUN Powered by ADP · ADP

    ADP's small-business payroll for 1-49 employees, with 24/7 phone and chat support and a tax filing penalty guarantee on every package. Pricing is quote-only, and W-2/1099 forms, time tracking and workers' comp cost extra on the entry Essential package.

  • Roll by ADP · ADP

    A chat-style, app-first payroll from ADP for very small teams, with one flat price ($39/mo + $5 per worker), unlimited runs, all 50 states and time tracking included. It has no benefits brokerage or HR tools, and support is mainly in-app chat.

  • Paychex Flex · Paychex

    Paychex's payroll and HR platform, whose entry Basic package covers unlimited payroll, tax filing and W-2/1099 processing, with room to grow into HR, benefits and PEO. Pricing is quote-only, and on Basic phone support, time tracking and garnishment service are add-ons.

  • SurePayroll · Paychex

    Low-cost online payroll from Paychex for micro businesses and household employers, with published pricing and unlimited runs. Watch the extras: multi-state payroll, local taxes and year-end W-2/1099 forms are billed separately, and standard direct deposit takes 2 days.

  • Paycor · Paychex

    HR and payroll platform aimed at growing teams; its Basic bundle for businesses under 50 employees covers payroll, tax filing and additional state tax authorities. Base fee is higher than app-style rivals, and time tracking, benefits admin and workers' comp are add-ons.

  • Paylocity · Paylocity

    Payroll and HR suite built for growing and midsize companies; small businesses start on the Express tier (payroll plus employee self-service and on-demand pay). Pricing is quote-only and per employee, and time tracking needs a higher tier.

  • Justworks Payroll · Justworks

    Justworks' non-PEO payroll plan at $50/month plus $8 per employee, with multi-state payroll, tax filings and phone support; health insurance, contractors and advanced time tracking cost extra per person. Its PEO plans (from $79/employee) add co-employment benefits and 24/7 support.

  • Wave Payroll · Wave Financial

    Low-cost payroll add-on to Wave's accounting software, suited to very small teams already using Wave. Tax service now covers all 50 states for customers who joined after April 2, 2025, but Wave does not file 1099s for you, and support is chat and email only.

  • Homebase Payroll · Homebase

    Payroll add-on to Homebase's scheduling and time-clock app, built for hourly teams such as restaurants and retail; it runs pay straight from timesheets with tip pooling. Benefits and workers' comp come through integrations rather than in-house, and phone support runs 7am-7pm CT.

  • Deel Payroll: US · Deel

    Self-serve US payroll at $29 per employee per month, best for companies that also pay international contractors or employees through Deel. Signup goes through a demo, and Deel says it is built for companies with fewer than 200 US employees; managed payroll and PEO plans cost more.

  • TriNet PEO · TriNet

    Full-service PEO that becomes co-employer, giving small and mid-size companies access to big-company health benefits, a TriNet 401(k), workers' comp and HR experts. Pricing is a flat per-employee monthly fee by quote only, with a minimum employee count and usually an annual agreement.

  • Paycom Payroll · Paycom

    All-in-one payroll and HR software on a single database, with a dedicated specialist for each client; it suits growing mid-size companies more than tiny teams. Pricing is quote-only and includes a one-time implementation fee.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons