Pillows

Compare popular bed pillows side by side: shredded and solid memory foam, latex, down, down alternative and kapok pillows from Coop, Tempur-Pedic, Purple, Saatva, Casper, Brooklinen, Parachute and more. The real choice is loft and firmness for the way you sleep, whether you can adjust it, how hot it sleeps, how you'll clean it, and how long you get to try it.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with how you sleep

  • Side sleepers need the most height to fill the gap between shoulder and head: a high-loft, firm or medium-firm pillow.
  • Back sleepers usually do best with medium loft and medium firmness, so the head isn't pushed forward.
  • Stomach sleepers need a low, soft pillow, or none, to keep the neck from bending back.
  • Combination sleepers who move around should look at adjustable or medium pillows that don't fight a change of position.

Your build and mattress matter too: broad shoulders need more loft, and a soft mattress you sink into needs less.

Pick a fill

  • Shredded memory foam molds to you and can usually be adjusted by adding or removing fill. It can sleep warm and smells a little at first.
  • Solid memory foam gives steady, contoured support but can't be adjusted and holds heat.
  • Latex is springy, durable and cooler than memory foam; it's heavier and costs more.
  • Down is soft, light and squishy, and lasts years with care, but gives less support and isn't for people with feather allergies.
  • Down alternative (polyester fiber) is cheap, washable and hypoallergenic, but flattens sooner.
  • Kapok and other plant fills feel like a soft, fluffy foam and suit people avoiding foam and feathers.

Rule out deal-breakers

  • Heat: if you sleep hot, look for latex, down, or cooling covers and ventilated foam.
  • Allergies: avoid down and feathers; a removable, washable cover helps with dust mites.
  • Cleaning: check whether the whole pillow can go in the washer or only the cover.

Compare full costs and terms

Compare the regular price for the same size (Queen is usual), since sale prices change weekly. A long trial is valuable because it takes one to three weeks to get used to a new pillow; check whether returns are free. Warranties mostly cover defects and permanent flattening, not normal softening.

Before you buy

  • Expect any pillow to soften over time; most need replacing every one to three years (latex and down last longer).
  • Foam pillows may smell for a few days after unboxing; air them out before deciding.
  • Certifications such as CertiPUR-US or OEKO-TEX check for harmful substances; they don't say anything about comfort.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$159
$139
$65
$75
$89
$114
$160
$229
$79
$100
$165
$135.99
$129
⠿
Size priced
Queen
Standard, soft (medium $149, firm $159)
Standard
Standard
Queen
Queen
Standard, soft (medium $185, firm $205)
Standard
one size (Standard/Queen)
Standard
Standard/Queen
Queen
Standard
⠿
Fill
shredded latex and kapok
down (Canadian)
shredded memory foam (cooling-infused)
down alternative (pillow-in-pillow)
shredded memory foam and microfiber
shredded memory foam and kapok
down (European white, 750 fill power)
solid latex (Talalay) with gel grid
solid memory foam
solid memory foam (Adaptive foam with graphite and gel)
shredded latex and down alternative
latex noodle and polyester fiber
memory foam and microfiber down alternative
⠿
Adjustable loft
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Loft options
adjustable (remove or add fill)
soft, medium, firm fill levels
adjustable (zip layer)
medium; low with inner pillow removed
adjustable (add or remove fill)
adjustable (remove fill)
soft, medium, firm fill levels
Low, Medium, Tall
one loft (low profile)
one loft (5 in)
Standard Loft, High Loft
adjustable (remove fill)
adjustable (zip-in layers)
⠿
Firmness
medium-firm, adjustable
soft, medium or firm
adjustable
medium
medium-firm, adjustable
adjustable
soft, medium or firm
medium
extra-soft
medium
medium
adjustable (add or remove fill)
soft, medium, or firm (set by zipping layers)
⠿
Sleep position
side, back, combination
soft for stomach, medium for back, firm for side
Not stated
side, back, stomach
side, back, stomach
side, stomach, all
any; pick soft, medium or firm to match
stomach, back, side, combination
back, stomach
side, back, stomach
all sleep positions; standard loft for back and stomach, high loft for side
side
all sleep positions
⠿
Cooling
breathable latex and kapok fill, cotton cover
none stated
cooling-infused memory foam
breathable cotton percale cover
breathable Lulltra cover
breathable hexagon-weave cover
none stated
GelFlex grid, ventilated latex
none stated
open-cell foam with graphite and cooling gel
breathable natural latex
cooling Dunlop latex noodle fill
cooling cover fabric
⠿
Removable washable cover
Yes
No
Not stated
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
⠿
Machine washable pillow
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Trial period
100 days
365 days
365 days
30 days
100 days
30 days
60 days
30 days
0 days
100 days
45 days
45 days
30 days
⠿
Warranty
1 years
1 years
1 years
1 years
5 years
5 years
3 years
1 years
5 years
3 years
1 years
5 years
1 years
⠿
Certifications
GOLS, GOTS, OEKO-TEX Standard 100, GREENGUARD Gold
OEKO-TEX Standard 100, Responsible Down Standard
None stated
None stated
CertiPUR-US, Greenguard Gold
CertiPUR-US
OEKO-TEX Standard 100, Responsible Down Standard
None stated
None stated
CertiPUR-US
none stated
OEKO-TEX Standard 100
None stated

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Pillows run from about $20 to over $200. More money buys better materials and longer trials, not necessarily a better fit for you.

  • Size priced

    Sizes cost different amounts, so check which size a price is for. Queen is the most common size quoted.

  • Fill

    Fill decides feel, support, heat and care. Foam and latex hold their shape; down is soft and squishy; down alternative is cheaper and hypoallergenic.

  • Adjustable loft

    An adjustable pillow can be tuned to your shoulder width and mattress, which helps if you're between sizes or share one type across sleepers.

  • Loft options

    Loft (height) matters more than anything else for neck alignment: side sleepers usually need higher, stomach sleepers lower.

  • Firmness

    Firmness is personal. Soft suits stomach sleepers and people who like to sink in; firm suits side sleepers who need support.

  • Sleep position

    Side sleepers need a higher, firmer pillow; back sleepers medium; stomach sleepers low and soft. Combination sleepers do best with adjustable or medium pillows.

  • Cooling

    Hot sleepers notice foam holding heat. Cooling covers and ventilated or latex fills help; down and fiber breathe naturally.

  • Removable washable cover

    A washable cover keeps the pillow clean without washing the whole thing, which matters most for foam and latex pillows that can't go in the washer.

  • Machine washable pillow

    Washing the whole pillow kills dust mites and removes sweat stains. Down and fiber pillows often can be washed; foam usually can't.

  • Trial period (days)

    A long trial lets you sleep on it for a few weeks, which is the only real way to judge a pillow. Check return shipping and restocking terms.

  • Warranty (years)

    A long warranty signals the maker expects the fill to keep its shape. It usually covers defects and flattening, not normal softening.

  • Certifications

    Certifications check for harmful chemicals (CertiPUR-US, OEKO-TEX), organic materials (GOTS, GOLS) or animal welfare (RDS for down).

About the products

  • Avocado Green Pillow · Avocado

    Certified-organic shredded latex and kapok in an organic cotton cover, adjustable by removing fill. Suits buyers avoiding synthetic foam; no polyester or petroleum foam inside.

  • Brooklinen Down Pillow · Brooklinen

    A classic Canadian down pillow sold in soft, medium and firm fills, matched to stomach, back and side sleepers. RDS and OEKO-TEX certified with a 365-day return window.

  • Marlow Pillow · Brooklinen

    A low-cost foam pillow with a zip-open side to adjust height and firmness, and cooling-infused foam. A cheaper alternative to the big adjustable brands.

  • Casper Original Pillow · Casper

    A down-alternative pillow-in-pillow: take out the inner pillow for a low loft. The whole pillow is machine washable; medium feel suits most back and side sleepers.

  • Coop Original Adjustable Pillow · Coop Sleep Goods

    The best-known adjustable pillow: a bag of shredded memory foam and microfiber you can add to or take out of to set height and firmness for any sleep position. Long 100-night trial and 5-year warranty.

  • Layla Kapok Pillow · Layla

    Shredded memory foam mixed with kapok fiber for a softer, moldable feel, with fill you can remove. Layla mostly sells it as buy-one-get-one, so compare the per-pillow cost.

  • Parachute Down Pillow · Parachute

    A premium 750 fill power European down pillow in soft, medium and firm. Machine washable, RDS certified, and the most expensive down option here.

  • Harmony Pillow · Purple

    A bouncy Talalay latex core wrapped in Purple's gel grid, sold in three heights. Sleeps cool and keeps its shape, but it's heavy, expensive and not adjustable.

  • TEMPUR-Cloud Pillow · Tempur-Pedic

    A soft, low solid-foam pillow that molds closely to the head, made for back and stomach sleepers. One fixed height, and Tempur-Pedic doesn't take pillow returns.

  • Tuft & Needle Original Foam Pillow · Tuft & Needle

    A solid foam pillow infused with graphite and gel to sleep cooler, in one 5-inch height. Simple and supportive, with a 100-night trial; only the cover is washable.

  • Saatva Latex Pillow · Saatva

    Shredded natural latex inside a down-alternative outer layer, in standard or high loft. Medium feel and breathable; not adjustable, so pick the loft that fits your sleep position.

  • Eli & Elm Side Sleeper Pillow · Eli & Elm

    A U-shaped pillow with a cut-out for the shoulder, made only for side sleepers, filled with latex noodles and fiber you can adjust. Not for back or stomach sleepers.

  • Tri-Comfort Cooling Pillow · Nectar

    A memory foam and down-alternative pillow with zip-in layers that set it soft, medium or firm, plus a cooling cover. Shorter 30-night trial than Nectar's mattresses.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons