Pizza stones and steels

Compare pizza stones and baking steels for your home oven or grill. Check how much space each needs, how long the maker recommends preheating, and whether a glazed stone, thin perforated steel or heavier plate suits the pizza you bake.

Last updated

How to choose

Measure the oven rack or grill first

Measure the clear width and depth and leave room for air to circulate. The outside dimension is what must fit; the Made In steel has an 11.5-inch cooking surface inside its 12.6-inch rim. Weber’s two stones use different systems. Check your grate and frame before ordering. The Ooni 10 mm stone also fits the Volt 2 as well as the Fyra, Koda 12 and original Volt.

Pick a surface for how you bake

A solid steel moves heat into dough quickly in a conventional oven. A thick steel can carry more heat into the next pizza but takes longer to preheat and may be awkward to lift. A stone is useful for pizza and bread; a larger one can still weigh as much as a steel. A thin perforated steel is easier to handle, but it behaves differently from a solid slab. Compare the cooking surface with the largest pizza you plan to make.

Check the heat and care instructions

A temperature rating is different from a preheat recommendation. FibraMent gives separate continuous and intermittent limits and requires a flame diverter on a grill. Bring a stone up to temperature as its maker directs and let it cool gradually. Follow the model’s cleaning advice: Ooni says to keep water off its stone, while Old Stone says to rinse and air dry. Dry seasoned steel after cleaning and oil it as directed.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price per baking surface
$139
$189
$54.99
$119
$47.29
$69.95
$44.95
$69.95
$35
$59.99
$99.99
$83.95
$99.99
⠿
Material
Solid carbon steel
Solid carbon steel
Carbon steel
Proprietary composite stone
Cordierite
Cordierite
Cordierite
Cordierite
Solid cordierite
Cordierite
Cordierite
Ceramic
High-performance BBQ ceramic
⠿
Dimensions
16 x 14 in
16 x 16 in
12.6 in total diameter; 11.5 in cooking surface
20 x 15 in
15 x 12 in
16 x 14 in
14 in diameter
16 in diameter
13.23 x 13.23 in
13.2 W x 16.7 D in, with carry rack
16 W x 16.3 D in
14.5 in outer diameter
14.5 in outer diameter
⠿
Thickness
0.25 in
0.375 in
0.079 in
0.75 in
0.6 in
0.59 in
0.6 in
0.6 in
0.4 in
Not stated
0.5 in
Not stated
1 in
⠿
Weight
15 lb
27 lb
2.6 lb
16.55 lb
6.8 lb
8.08 lb
3.75 lb
7.28 lb
Not stated
6 lb
10.2 lb
5.5 lb
6.4 lb
⠿
Maximum temperature
Not stated
Not stated
1,200°F
1,000°F
1,450°F
1,450°F
1,450°F
1,450°F
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
930°F
930°F
⠿
Grill use
Yes: gas or charcoal grill
Yes: grill
Yes: grill, oven, or pizza oven
Yes: flame diverter required
Yes: grill; maker suggests round for kettles
Yes: home oven, pizza oven or grill
Yes: residential ovens, pizza ovens, and grills
Yes: residential ovens, pizza ovens, and grills
Not stated
Yes: Gourmet BBQ System or select Weber Crafted setups
Yes: Weber Crafted compatible grill, frame, and grates required
Yes: gas or charcoal
Yes: gas or charcoal grill
⠿
Maintenance
Wipe after cooling; dry and lightly oil; no dishwasher
Scrape and wipe dry once cool; skip soap
Hand wash only
Wipe dry; loosen residue with rubber spatula
Scrape; hand wash with water; no detergent
Rinse and air dry; hand wash only
Rinse and air dry; hand wash only
Rinse and air dry; hand wash only
Dry brush or scrape; no water or soap
Brush clean and rinse with water; no soap
Hand wash
Dishwasher safe
Dishwasher safe
⠿
Shape
Rectangular
Square
Round
Rectangular
Rectangular
Rectangular
Round
Round
Square
Round
Rectangular
Round
Round
⠿
Pre seasoned
Yes
Yes
Yes
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
⠿
Fits
Home oven or gas/charcoal grill
Home oven, grill or stovetop
Home oven, pizza oven or grill
Home oven; grill with flame diverter
Home oven or grill
Home oven, pizza oven or grill
Home oven, pizza oven or grill
Home oven, pizza oven or grill
Home oven; Ooni Fyra, Koda 12, Volt and Volt 2
Gourmet BBQ System; select Weber Crafted setups
Compatible Genesis, Spirit and SmokeFire grills with Crafted frame and grates
Home oven, gas or charcoal grill, microwave
Oven, gas or charcoal grill, microwave
⠿
Surface finish
Solid seasoned steel
Solid seasoned steel
Perforated seasoned steel
Rough and smooth stone sides
Smooth porous stone; reversible
Unglazed stone
Unglazed stone
Unglazed stone
Unglazed stone
Unglazed stone
Stone with glaze
Smooth sealed ceramic
Sealed, ridged ceramic
⠿
Recommended preheat
60 min, in home oven
60 min to 75 min in home oven
about 30 min, in home oven
30 min to 45 min in home oven
Not stated
20 min to 25 min in oven or on grill
20 min to 25 min in oven or on grill
20 min to 25 min in oven or on grill
Not stated
Not stated
10 min to 15 min on grill
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Warranty
Lifetime against defects
Lifetime against defects
Limited lifetime
10 years against defects
Not stated
Limited lifetime to original owner
Limited lifetime to original owner
Limited lifetime to original owner
1 year against defects
2 years limited
2 years limited
10 years against defects
10 years against defects

Why these features matter

  • Price per baking surface ($)

    Price helps compare a low-cost stone with heavier or specialty steels.

  • Material

    Steel and ceramic or cordierite stones transfer and retain heat differently.

  • Dimensions

    Measure oven racks and grill openings before buying.

  • Thickness (in)

    Thickness affects stored heat, preheat time, and lifting weight.

  • Weight (lb)

    A heavy surface can store more heat but is harder to move while hot.

  • Maximum temperature (°F)

    Check the stated limit before using a surface in a high-heat oven or grill.

  • Grill use

    Some surfaces are made for a home oven or specific grill insert only.

  • Maintenance

    Steel may need oiling while ceramic surfaces often have different cleaning rules.

  • Shape

    A rectangular surface offers space for bread and sheet-style pizza; a round surface can fit kettle grills.

  • Pre seasoned

    A pre-seasoned steel works from the first bake; stones need no seasoning at all.

  • Fits

    A stone cut for one oven or grill may not fit another.

  • Surface finish

    Glaze, texture and perforations affect cleaning and how the crust makes contact.

  • Recommended preheat (min)

    The oven can reach temperature before a thick surface is ready to cook.

  • Warranty

    Warranty length helps when a new surface arrives with a defect.

About the products

  • Original Pizza Steel · Baking Steel

    Pre-seasoned carbon steel plate for home ovens, grills, and stovetops.

  • Pro Pizza Steel · Baking Steel

    A 27 lb, 3/8 in steel for full-size pizzas and several bakes in a row. Check the rack and the weight before buying.

  • Pizza Steel 12.6 in · Made In

    Thin perforated carbon-steel disk with a smaller cooking surface and high heat rating.

  • Home Oven Baking Stone 20 x 15 in · FibraMent

    A thick rectangular stone with room for larger pizzas and bread. Allow an inch of airflow on every side; use the separate grill setup if cooking over a flame.

  • Rectangular Pizza Stone 15 x 12 in · Unicook

    A low-cost cordierite stone for home ovens and grills, with a scraper included. The maker recommends it for pizzas up to 11 inches.

  • Rectangular Pizza Stone 14 x 16 in · Old Stone Pizza Kitchen

    A rectangular cordierite stone for baking pizza or bread in an oven or on a grill.

  • Round Pizza Stone 14 in · Old Stone Pizza Kitchen

    Cordierite round stone rated for home ovens, pizza ovens, and grills.

  • Round Pizza Stone 16 in · Old Stone Pizza Kitchen

    Sixteen-inch cordierite stone rated for home ovens, pizza ovens, and grills.

  • Pizza Stone 10 mm · Ooni

    Compact cordierite replacement for select Ooni ovens, including the Volt 2. Ooni also approves it for conventional ovens.

  • Gourmet BBQ System Pizza Stone #8836 · Weber

    Round cordierite stone with a carrying rack. Weber lists compatible Gourmet BBQ System grates and select Weber Crafted setups.

  • Crafted Pizza Stone #7671 · Weber

    Glazed cordierite insert for Weber Crafted-compatible grills.

  • Smooth Pizza Stone 14.5 in · Emile Henry

    A smooth, sealed ceramic stone for a home oven or grill. Its round surface has carry handles and the maker lists it as dishwasher safe.

  • Ridged Pizza Stone 14.5 in · Emile Henry

    Round ridged ceramic stone with a low edge for peel access and a high rear edge to help keep pizza from sliding. The maker lists oven, barbecue, microwave, and dishwasher use.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons