Bird feeders

Bird feeders range from simple seed tubes and hoppers to squirrel-proof designs and solar camera feeders that identify visiting species. This grid compares popular US models on price, what they hold, squirrel resistance, ease of cleaning, and what the smart ones cost to run.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with the birds you want to attract, then the pests you want to keep out.

Pick the food and feeder type

  • Black oil sunflower seed suits most songbirds and fits hoppers and tube feeders.
  • Nyjer (thistle) draws goldfinches and needs a feeder with very small ports.
  • Suet cakes feed woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees and need a suet cage or feeder.
  • Window feeders stick to the glass with suction cups for close-up viewing, but hold little.

Decide how much squirrels matter

If squirrels raid your yard, a weight-activated feeder that closes its ports or perches under their weight saves seed and money. It costs more up front. Without squirrels, a plain tube or hopper does the job. Note where you will hang it: squirrels jump, so mounting height and distance from branches count as much as the feeder.

Compare capacity and cleaning

A bigger hopper means fewer refills, but seed that sits too long goes bad. Look for a feeder you can take apart or open from the top, because dirty feeders can spread disease among birds. Wash them regularly and let them dry before refilling.

Think about a camera feeder

Smart feeders add a camera and species identification. Check the full cost: some features need a paid plan after a trial, and the feeder needs sun, a battery charge or a nearby power source. Also check Wi-Fi reach where you plan to hang it.

Check the warranty

Warranties run from one year to limited lifetime. For a feeder that lives outdoors, a longer one is worth a look.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$129.25
$59.95
$109.95
$149.95
$39.95
$34.95
$219.99
$159
⠿
Feeder type
Squirrel-proof tube feeder
Squirrel-proof tube feeder
Squirrel-proof suet feeder
Hopper feeder
Tube feeder
Window feeder
Smart camera feeder
Smart camera feeder
⠿
Foods it holds
Birdseed
Birdseed
Suet cakes (holds 2)
Black oil sunflower seed, specialty blends
Nyjer seed
Black oil sunflower seed
Birdseed
Seed
⠿
Seed capacity
5.1 lb
1.3 lb
Doesn't apply
12 lb
1.5 lb
Doesn't apply
2.7 lb
1.6 lb
⠿
Feeding ports
Not stated
4
Doesn't apply
Not stated
8
Doesn't apply
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Squirrel resistance
Weight-activated closing shroud
Weight-activated closing shroud
Weight-activated closing shroud
Weight-activated perches shut off seed
None claimed
None claimed
None claimed
None claimed
⠿
Material
Metal, plastic, resin
Metal, plastic, resin
Metal and plastic
All steel
Plastic
Plastic
PC and ABS plastic
Not stated
⠿
Mounting
Hangs from brackets, extension hooks or tree hooks
Hangs from brackets, extension hooks or tree hooks
Hangs from brackets, extension hooks or tree hooks
Hang or pole-mount; hanger and 58 in pole included
Hanging
Window mount, three suction cups
Hanging or mounting bracket included
Hanging or pole mount; hanger and pole mount included
⠿
Height
28 in
13.25 in
18.625 in
Not stated
15.5 in
Not stated
10.6 in
6.95 in
⠿
Has camera
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Camera resolution
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
2K high quality; 1080p standard
2K video; 5 MP photos
⠿
Power
None needed
None needed
None needed
None needed
None needed
None needed
5200 mAh rechargeable battery; solar panel optional
Solar roof; USB-C rechargeable battery
⠿
Subscription for full features
None
None
None
None
None
None
Bird ID free for life; optional Plus plan $79.99
Premium $69.99/year after free trial
⠿
Warranty
Limited lifetime, material and manufacturing defects
Limited lifetime, material and manufacturing defects
Limited lifetime, material and manufacturing defects
1 year guarantee, exchange or refund
1 year guarantee, exchange or refund
1 year guarantee, exchange or refund
2 years plus lifetime support
24 months from delivery
⠿
Easy cleaning
Takes apart by hand, no tools
Takes apart by hand, no tools
Takes apart by hand, no tools
Lift-up roof for cleaning and filling
Fills from the top, easy to clean
Easy to clean and fill
Bottom knob for easy disassembly
Wash feeder and tray, dry before refilling

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Feeders run from about $20 to over $150, and smart feeders add an optional subscription; compare cost over the years you will keep it.

  • Feeder type

    Style decides which birds come and how much seed spills or spoils.

    Tube
    : Vertical seed tube with ports and perches. Good for small songbirds; less so for larger birds.
    Hopper
    : A roofed box that releases seed into a tray. Holds a lot and attracts a wider mix of birds.
  • Foods it holds

    A feeder built for one food does poorly with another; match it to the birds you want.

    Nyjer
    : Tiny black thistle seed that goldfinches and other finches love; needs a feeder with very small ports.
  • Seed capacity (lb)

    Larger capacity means fewer refills; small capacity keeps seed fresh in slow seasons.

  • Feeding ports

    More ports let more birds eat at once, which reduces squabbles.

  • Squirrel resistance

    Squirrels empty ordinary feeders in a day; a true squirrel-proof design saves seed but costs more.

    Weight-activated
    : A perch or shroud closes the seed ports when a squirrel's weight lands on it. Worth it if squirrels empty your feeder; skip it if you have none.
  • Material

    Metal lasts longer and resists chewing; plastic is cheaper and lighter.

  • Mounting

    Mounting decides where it can go and whether a pole must be bought separately.

  • Height (in)

    Taller feeders need more hanging room and are harder to reach.

  • Has camera

    Camera feeders let you watch and identify birds from a phone.

  • Camera resolution

    Higher resolution gives clearer bird photos, but wifi range and the app matter as much.

  • Power

    Solar models avoid charging chores; non-powered feeders have nothing to charge.

  • Subscription for full features

    Subscriptions add yearly cost and sometimes gate cloud video or the best AI identification.

  • Warranty

    A longer guarantee shows how long the maker expects the feeder to last.

  • Easy cleaning

    Dirty feeders spread disease, so one you can take apart quickly gets cleaned more often.

About the products

  • Squirrel Buster Plus · Brome

    Largest tube feeder in Brome's squirrel-proof line; the shroud closes the ports under a squirrel's weight. Suits seed eaters who fight squirrels daily.

  • Squirrel Buster Standard · Brome

    Smaller, cheaper version of the weight-activated Squirrel Buster tube feeder.

  • Squirrel Buster Suet · Brome

    Squirrel-proof suet feeder for woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees.

  • Absolute II · Duncraft

    Large all-steel hopper with spring-loaded perches that shut under a squirrel's weight; high capacity.

  • Classic Nyjer Tube · Duncraft

    Simple tube feeder with tiny ports for nyjer (thistle) seed; aimed at goldfinches and other finches.

  • Cardinal Classic Window Feeder · Duncraft

    Small tray feeder that sticks to a window for close-up viewing.

  • Birdfy Feeder (solar) · Birdfy

    Smart feeder with built-in camera and AI bird identification, powered by a solar panel.

  • Birdbuddy Nook Solar · Bird Buddy

    Smart camera feeder with AI species identification and a solar roof.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons