Health insurance plans

Health insurance plans come in two overlapping labels: a metal category (bronze, silver, gold, platinum, catastrophic) that sets how you and the plan split costs, and a network type (HMO, PPO, EPO, POS) that sets which doctors you can see. This grid compares each, plus HSA-eligible high-deductible plans, so you can weigh a lower premium against higher costs when you need care.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with how much care you expect to use. Rarely sick and want protection from a disaster: a bronze or catastrophic plan keeps premiums low. Regular prescriptions, therapy or planned surgery: compare Silver and Gold with other categories. Lower cost sharing can offset a higher premium, depending on the plan and any savings you qualify for.

Steps

  1. Check for savings first. If your income qualifies for extra savings (cost-sharing reductions), they only apply to silver plans, which can make silver the best value.
  2. Pick a metal category by your total yearly cost (premiums plus what you pay at the doctor), not the premium alone.
  3. Pick a network type. HMO and EPO plans limit you to their network; PPO plans let you go outside it for more money; POS plans need a referral for specialists.
  4. Check your doctors and drugs are in the plan before you enroll.
  5. Consider an HSA-eligible plan if you want to set money aside tax-free for medical costs.

Pitfalls

  • The metal names say nothing about quality of care.
  • Percentages shown are averages across all people on a plan, not what you will personally pay.
  • Catastrophic plans are only open to people under 30 or with a hardship or affordability exemption.

Employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage work differently and are not covered here.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide services and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the company doesn't publish it

FeatureService ⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
HMO
Links
⠿
PPO
Links
⠿
EPO
Links
⠿
POS
Links
⠿
⠿
Plan share of costs
60% on average
70% on average
80% on average
90% on average
Not stated
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
⠿
Deductible level
High
Moderate
Low
Low
Very high
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Higher than a traditional plan
⠿
Premium level
Lower
Moderate
Higher
Highest
Low
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Set by metal level
Usually lower
⠿
Out of network coverage
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Emergencies only
Covered, for an extra cost
Emergencies only
Covered, for an extra cost
Depends on network type
⠿
Specialist referral
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Depends on network type
Usually required
Not required
Not stated
Required
Depends on network type
⠿
HSA compatibility
All plans
Some plans
Some plans
Some plans
All plans
Some plans
Some plans
Some plans
Some plans
All plans
⠿
Extra savings on out of pocket costs
No
Yes, if income qualifies
No
No
No
Only on silver plans
Only on silver plans
Only on silver plans
Only on silver plans
Only on silver plans
⠿
Who can enroll
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Under 30, or hardship or affordability exemption
May need to live or work in its service area
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
Anyone eligible for Marketplace coverage
⠿
Covers the 10 essential health benefits
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Why these features matter

  • Plan share of costs

    The bigger the plan's share, the less you pay when you use care, but premiums rise to match.

  • Deductible level

    A high deductible means big bills at first even if you are insured; it matters most if you expect regular care.

  • Premium level

    The premium is paid every month whether or not you use care, so weigh it against expected costs.

  • Out of network coverage

    If you travel, see a favorite specialist or live in a thin network, out-of-network coverage can decide which plan works.

  • Specialist referral

    Referral rules add steps and delays; people who see specialists often may prefer plans that skip them.

  • HSA compatibility

    An HSA lets you pay medical costs with pre-tax money, which helps most if you can save and expect low-to-moderate care.

  • Extra savings on out of pocket costs

    These savings are large but only available on silver plans, so they change which category is best.

  • Who can enroll

    Some plans have limits that rule them out before you compare price.

  • Covers the 10 essential health benefits

    Every Marketplace plan covers the same core services, so the choice is about cost and network, not coverage of the basics.

About the services

  • Bronze plan

    Marketplace plan where the plan pays about 60% of costs. Lowest premiums of the four metal levels but a high deductible; suits healthy people who want protection from big bills.

  • Silver plan

    Marketplace plan paying about 70% of costs. The only category that gets extra savings on deductibles and copays if your income qualifies, so it can beat gold on value.

  • Gold plan

    Marketplace plan paying about 80% of costs. Higher premiums, lower deductible and copays; suits regular users of care and prescriptions.

  • Platinum plan

    Marketplace plan paying about 90% of costs. Highest premiums, lowest costs at the doctor; suits people with frequent or expensive care.

  • Catastrophic plan

    Low premium, very high deductible plan for worst-case events. Only people under 30 or with a hardship or affordability exemption can buy one.

  • HMO

    Network type that usually covers only doctors who work for or contract with the plan. Often lower cost with coordinated care, but little out-of-network coverage.

  • PPO

    Network type with the most freedom: you pay less in network but can see out-of-network providers, without a referral, for more money. Premiums are often higher.

  • EPO

    Network type covering only in-network providers (except emergencies), but without the referral rules of a POS plan. Sits between an HMO and a PPO.

  • POS

    Network type where you pay less in network, can go out of network at higher cost, and need a referral from your primary care doctor to see a specialist.

  • HSA-eligible high-deductible plan

    Plan with a higher deductible and usually lower premium that lets you contribute to a tax-free health savings account (HSA). All bronze and catastrophic plans qualify.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons