Vision insurance plans

Vision insurance helps pay for eye exams, glasses and contact lenses, but most plans reimburse a fixed allowance rather than the full cost. This grid compares standalone individual and family plans from Aetna, EyeMed, Guardian and Humana on premium, copays, frame and contact lens allowances, waiting periods and networks, so you can see whether a plan is worth its price.

Last updated

How to choose

Vision insurance is a small, predictable benefit, not protection against a big bill. Start by adding up what you really spend in a year, then see which plan would pay back more than its premiums.

1. Work out your needs

  • Do you wear glasses, contacts, or neither? Pick plans with a real frame allowance (glasses) or contact lens allowance (contacts).
  • Do you need a yearly exam? A low exam copay may be most of the value.
  • How many people will be covered? Premiums rise with family size.

2. Rule out deal-breakers

  • Check state availability first; not every plan is sold everywhere.
  • Check that your eye doctor or favorite optical chain is in the plan network. Some chains, such as Costco and Walmart, are not in network for Guardian plans sold online.
  • Look for waiting periods; the plans here have none.

3. Compare the key features

  • Annual cost: 12 times the monthly premium, plus the copays you expect to pay.
  • Benefit: the exam, frame allowance, contact lens allowance and lens copay add up to what the plan can pay in a year.
  • Discount-only plans, such as EyeMed Healthy, cost less but pay nothing toward frames, lenses or contacts.

4. Mind the fine print

  • Monthly prices shown are starting prices; your actual quote depends on age, state and family size.
  • Benefit periods differ: every 12 months from your last visit versus once per plan year.
  • Contact lens allowances usually replace your glasses benefit.
  • Out-of-network care is reimbursed at lower amounts, and you pay first.

Finally, get a quote for your zip code and compare the total premium to the benefit you would use.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide services and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the company doesn't publish it

FeatureService ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Starting monthly premium
$11/month
$14/month
$19/month
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
$5/month
$17.50/month
$30/month
⠿
Eye exam copay
$20
$15
$10
$15
$15
$15
$10
$0
$10
$10
⠿
Frames covered
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Frame allowance
$130
$160
$200
$150
$160
$225
$200
Doesn't apply
$130
$200
⠿
Contact lenses covered
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Contact lens allowance
$130
$160
$200
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
$200
Doesn't apply
$130
$200
⠿
Standard lenses covered
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Standard lens copay
$25
$20
$10
$25
$25
$25
$10
Doesn't apply
$20
$20
⠿
No waiting period
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Extra pair discount
40%
40%
40%
20%
20%
20%
Not stated
40%
40%
40%
⠿
Out of network coverage
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Provider network
EyeMed network: independents and retail chains
EyeMed network: independents and retail chains
EyeMed network: independents and retail chains
VSP network; Costco and Walmart not in network
VSP network; Costco and Walmart not in network
VSP network; Costco and Walmart not in network
Humana network, 170,000+ access points
EyeMed network: independents, retailers, online
EyeMed network: independents, retailers, online
EyeMed network: independents, retailers, online
⠿
Exam frequency
Every 12 months
Every 12 months
Every 12 months
Once a year
Once a year
Once a year
Every 12 months
Once per plan year
Once per plan year
Once per plan year
⠿
State availability
Varies by state
Varies by state
Varies by state
Not AZ or NM
Not AZ or NM
Not AZ or NM
Not all states
48 states
48 states
48 states

Why these features matter

  • Starting monthly premium ($/month)

    Premium is the price of the plan before you use it. Compare it with how much you will actually spend on exams, glasses or contacts in a year.

  • Eye exam copay ($)

    The exam is the one thing everybody uses every year. A low copay matters most if you do not buy new glasses annually.

  • Frames covered

    Discount-only plans can be cheap, but they pay nothing toward frames; you only save a percentage.

  • Frame allowance ($)

    Frames are often the biggest eyewear cost. A bigger allowance matters if you wear glasses and like designer frames.

  • Contact lenses covered

    Contact wearers need this: some plans cover only glasses benefits or give just a discount.

  • Contact lens allowance ($)

    Contacts are usually used in place of glasses, so this allowance is what offsets a year of lenses.

  • Standard lenses covered

    Lenses can cost as much as frames. A plan that pays for them cuts the bill for any prescription.

  • Standard lens copay ($)

    A copay is what you pay at the counter even before the allowance applies.

  • No waiting period

    Some vision plans make new members wait months. With no waiting period you can buy a plan and use it for glasses right away.

  • Extra pair discount (%)

    A second pair (sunglasses, spare, computer glasses) is common; the discount shows how far the plan helps beyond the first pair.

  • Out of network coverage

    Out-of-network benefits matter if your own eye doctor is not in the plan network, but you usually pay first and file a claim.

  • Provider network

    Check that your eye doctor or favorite optical chain is in network; it decides how much you save.

  • Exam frequency

    Every 12 months from your last visit and once per plan year behave differently if you shift appointment dates.

  • State availability

    Individual vision plans are not sold in every state, so check yours before you compare prices.

About the services

  • Aetna Vision Preferred Direct Value · Aetna

    The lowest-priced Aetna individual plan: a $20 exam copay and $130 toward frames or contacts. Uses the EyeMed network, which includes LensCrafters, Pearle Vision and Target Optical.

  • Aetna Vision Preferred Direct Select · Aetna

    The middle Aetna plan: $15 exam copay and $160 toward frames or contacts, with no deductible or waiting period.

  • Aetna Vision Preferred Direct Elite · Aetna

    The richest Aetna individual plan: $10 exam copay, $10 lens copay, and $200 toward frames or contacts.

  • Guardian Vision Standard · Guardian

    Guardian individual plan powered by VSP, with a $150 frame allowance. Big chains such as Costco and Walmart are not in network.

  • Guardian Vision Core · Guardian

    Guardian individual plan powered by VSP, with a $160 frame allowance. Big chains such as Costco and Walmart are not in network.

  • Guardian Vision Achiever · Guardian

    Guardian's most comprehensive individual plan (powered by VSP), with a $225 frame allowance, the largest in this grid.

  • Humana Vision PLUS · Humana

    Humana's individual vision plan: $10 exam copay (or $0 at a Plus network provider), $200 for frames or contacts, and no waiting period. Plus network providers get a $250 frame allowance.

  • EyeMed Healthy · EyeMed

    EyeMed's cheapest plan: a covered eye exam plus discounts on glasses and contacts, but no frame, lens or contact allowance. Best for people who mostly want the exam.

  • EyeMed Bold · EyeMed

    Essential EyeMed coverage: $10 exam copay, $130 toward frames or contacts, and $20 lens copay.

  • EyeMed Bright · EyeMed

    EyeMed's fullest plan: $10 exam copay, $200 toward frames or contacts, and $20 lens copay.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons