Personal-item travel bags

A personal item is the one free bag almost every airline lets you bring on board, as long as it fits under the seat in front of you. On basic-economy fares and budget airlines it can be the only free bag, so the right one decides whether you pay a bag fee. This grid compares backpacks, totes, duffels and small wheeled bags built for that space: how big they really are against airline limits, how much they hold, how easily you can get at your things, and what they weigh before you pack anything.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with your airline's limit

Personal-item limits are not standard. Many US airlines quote about 18 x 14 x 8 inches, but some are smaller (United publishes 17 x 10 x 9 inches and JetBlue 17 x 13 x 8, and budget airlines such as Spirit and Frontier check bags in sizers). Check the airlines you fly most, and compare the bag's Height, Width and Depth, not just its liters. Soft bags can squash a little; a wheeled bag's frame can't.

Pick a shape

  • Backpacks keep your hands free and are easiest through long terminals and on foot at your destination.
  • Totes and duffels are quick to dig into at your seat and squash into odd spaces, but a full one is heavy on one shoulder. A trolley sleeve lets you ride it on a suitcase.
  • Wheeled underseaters save your back, but the wheels and handle eat space and weight, and they're awkward on stairs, cobbles and in small cabins.

Then compare what matters to you

  • Capacity and weight: a few liters more is a day more clothes; a heavy empty bag eats into strict weight limits abroad.
  • Access: a bag that opens flat (clamshell) packs like a suitcase; a top opening is quicker for a jacket or snack but harder to pack neatly.
  • Laptop: check the largest screen size it takes, and whether the laptop has its own compartment for security lines.
  • Expandable: extra room is handy for the trip home, but an expanded bag may no longer fit the sizer.
  • Durability and warranty: heavier fabrics and long warranties matter if you fly often.

Watch out for

  • Makers measure differently: some leave out handles, pockets or wheels. Leave a little margin.
  • "Personal item size" on a listing is a claim, not a promise; gate agents decide.
  • An overstuffed bag grows in depth, which is usually the dimension that fails.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Bag type
backpack
backpack
backpack
backpack
backpack
convertible (backpack or briefcase)
tote (converts to crossbody)
tote
duffel
duffel
duffel
tote
rolling underseater
rolling underseater
⠿
Price
$110
$125
$215
$49.99
$269
$349.99
$198
$168
$108
$138
$210
$90
$135
$51.45
⠿
Capacity
26 L, expands to 32 L
21 L
14 L
Not stated
24 L
20 L, expands to 30 L
20 L
27.1 L
32 L
25 L
18 L
28 L
26 L
22 L
⠿
Height
17 in
17.3 in
16.5 in
18.3 in
18 in
18.5 in
16.3 in
15 in
16.14 in
16 in
14.5 in
16 in
17.5 in
14.2 in
⠿
Width
13 in
11.6 in
11.2 in
13 in
12 in
12 in
10.2 in
14 in
15.75 in
12 in
9 in
11 in
14.5 in
13.4 in
⠿
Depth
6 in
6.5 in
6 in
7.8 in
8.8 in
6 in
7.3 in
7 in
7.87 in
8 in
7.5 in
8 in
8.5 in
9.5 in
⠿
Weight
1.85 lb
1 lb
2.68 lb
1.94 lb
2.1 lb
4.1 lb
2.25 lb
2.2 lb
3.11 lb
2 lb
2.5 lb
1.6 lb
5.5 lb
4.7 lb
⠿
Expandable
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
⠿
Main compartment opening
clamshell (suitcase-style full zip)
top zip
clamshell
Not stated
wide top entry
clamshell (opens flat)
full wraparound zip
top zip
wide-open top
top zip
top zip
top zip
large zip opening
Not stated
⠿
Laptop size
16 in
16 in
15 in
17 in
15 in
16 in
16 in
Not stated
16 in
Doesn't apply
13 in
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Separate laptop compartment
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Trolley sleeve
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Water bottle pocket
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
⠿
Carry options
backpack straps, top, side and bottom grab handles
backpack straps, top handle
backpack straps, top handle
backpack straps
backpack straps
backpack straps, briefcase carry, luggage handle pass-through
detachable shoulder strap, top handles
padded messenger shoulder strap
padded carry straps
shoulder strap, padded handles
detachable crossbody strap
top handles, rear strap for a suitcase handle
telescoping handle, two wheels
telescoping handle, two in-line skate wheels, four-point lift handle
⠿
Lockable zippers
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
⠿
Shoe compartment
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Main fabric
100% recycled 300D ripstop polyester
ECOPAK EPX70RS recycled waterproof sailcloth
premium nylon twill
polyester
800D nylon
water-resistant tarpaulin (nylon + polyester blend)
water repellent nylon, leather trim
600D recycled polyester
recycled polyester, virgin polyester, nylon webbing
polyester
neoprene
polyester with DuraGuard coating
polyester with DuraGuard coating
polyester
⠿
Warranty
All Mighty Guarantee
guaranteed against defects (length not stated)
2 years, limited
lifetime (defects)
lifetime guarantee
lifetime
1 year, limited
1 year
limited lifetime
1 year, limited
2 years, limited
limited lifetime
limited lifetime
1 year limited

Why these features matter

  • Bag type

    Shape decides how you carry it. Backpacks free your hands, totes and duffels are quickest to dig into at your seat, and wheeled bags save your back but lose space to the frame.

  • Price ($)

    A personal item is often bought to avoid a bag fee, so it pays for itself fast; spending more mostly buys tougher fabric, better organization and a longer warranty.

  • Capacity (L)

    More liters means more clothes, but makers measure liters differently, so compare dimensions too. Around 20 to 25 liters is enough for a weekend for most people.

  • Height (in)

    Airlines check all three sides. Many US airlines allow about 18 inches; some allow only 17, and budget airlines measure strictly with a sizer.

  • Width (in)

    Width usually fits easily, but United allows only 10 inches, so some wide bags are a squeeze there.

  • Depth (in)

    Depth is the side that grows when you overpack, and it's the one sizers catch most often. 8 inches is a common limit.

  • Weight (lb)

    Every pound the bag weighs is a pound you can't pack, which matters on airlines abroad that weigh cabin bags, and when you carry it all day.

  • Expandable

    Extra room helps on the way home with souvenirs, but an expanded bag may no longer fit under the seat or in a sizer.

  • Main compartment opening

    A bag that opens flat packs and unpacks like a suitcase; a top opening is faster for grabbing a jacket but makes the bottom hard to reach.

  • Laptop size (in)

    If you work on the go, make sure your laptop fits; a bag with no stated size may only take small tablets.

  • Separate laptop compartment

    Lets you pull the laptop out at security or on a tray table without unpacking everything.

  • Trolley sleeve

    Lets the bag ride on your rolling carry-on through the airport, which matters most for heavy totes and duffels.

  • Water bottle pocket

    Keeps a bottle upright and away from your laptop and clothes, and reachable at your seat.

  • Carry options

    More ways to carry it means fewer sore shoulders; a shoulder strap or backpack straps matter if you walk far.

  • Lockable zippers

    A lock won't stop a determined thief, but it deters quick grabs from an unattended bag and in hostels.

  • Shoe compartment

    Keeps dirty shoes off clean clothes on short trips, at the cost of some flexible space.

  • Main fabric

    Higher-denier nylons and coated fabrics resist scuffs and rain better; lighter fabrics save weight but wear faster.

  • Warranty

    A long warranty matters if you fly often; check whether it covers airline damage or only defects.

About the products

  • Daylite Expandable Travel Pack 26+6 · Osprey

    A light, inexpensive backpack sized to Osprey's take on international personal-item limits, with a suitcase-style opening and a zip that adds 6 liters. Expanded, it becomes a carry-on rather than a personal item; the laptop sleeve is a simple one.

  • Daypack Pro · Tortuga

    An ultralight (about 1 lb) 21-liter daypack in waterproof recycled sailcloth that Tortuga sells as a personal item and that packs flat inside other luggage. Simple organization; it was sold out on Tortuga's store when checked.

  • Metro Backpack · Monos

    A slim, polished 14-liter commuter-style backpack with a 15-inch laptop compartment and trolley sleeve. The smallest bag here, and on the heavy side for its size, so it suits light packers who want a smart look.

  • Travel Laptop Backpack (17 in) · Matein

    A popular budget backpack with a separate compartment for laptops up to 17 inches, a luggage sleeve and an anti-theft back pocket. Cheap and light, but basic polyester, and at 18.3 inches tall it's over some airlines' limits.

  • ZDX Cargo Backpack · Briggs & Riley

    A premium 24-liter backpack in 800D nylon with a wide top entry, a separate laptop section and Briggs & Riley's lifetime guarantee. At 8.8 inches deep it can be tight against 8-inch limits.

  • Travel Pack 20L · Nomatic

    A highly organized clamshell pack that carries as a backpack or briefcase, with a shoe compartment, separate laptop section and expansion from 20 to 30 liters. Expensive and heavy (4.1 lb), and fully expanded it may count as a carry-on.

  • The Everywhere Bag · Away

    A structured 20-liter tote that also carries crossbody, with a full wraparound zip, an exterior padded laptop pocket for up to 16 inches and a trolley sleeve. Only a one-year warranty.

  • Catalina Deluxe Tote · Lo & Sons

    A roomy 27-liter tote with a zip-off bottom shoe compartment, a padded messenger strap and a trolley sleeve. Holds a lot for an under-seat bag, but the zippers can't be locked and the warranty is one year.

  • The Mini Weekender · BÉIS

    A 32-liter soft duffel with a separate bottom shoe compartment, a magnetic padded laptop pocket for up to 16 inches and a trolley sleeve. Big capacity for the price, but it's nearly 16 inches in two directions, so it can be a squeeze under smaller seats.

  • Luka Duffel · CALPAK

    A 25-liter duffel CALPAK rates as a personal item, with a shoe compartment, water bottle pocket and trolley sleeve. It has no laptop compartment, and CALPAK sells it as final sale.

  • Landon Carryall (Medium) · Dagne Dover

    A soft neoprene duffel that snaps between two sizes, with a padded laptop sleeve, shoe bag and crossbody strap. Smallest capacity of the duffels here (about 18 liters) and fits only around a 13-inch laptop.

  • Maxlite 5 Soft Tote · Travelpro

    A very light (1.6 lb), low-cost 28-liter soft tote with a strap to ride on a suitcase handle and a limited lifetime warranty. Few organization extras.

  • Maxlite 5 Rolling Underseat Carry-On · Travelpro

    A 26-liter wheeled underseater with a telescoping handle and a limited lifetime warranty. Travelpro sizes it for mainline jets of major US airlines; on small regional planes it may have to go overhead. Wheels add weight (5.5 lb).

  • Amazon Basics Underseat Carry-On (14 in) · Amazon

    The cheapest wheeled underseater here: a 22-liter soft roller with a telescoping handle and a sleeve for larger luggage. Heavy for its size (4.7 lb) and 9.5 inches deep, deeper than many airlines' 8-inch limit.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons