Grass seed

Grass seed comes as single species, regional blends, and seed-plus-fertilizer products, and the right one depends on your climate, how much sun the spot gets, and whether you are starting a new lawn, overseeding, or patching. This grid compares the main national brand lines and farm-direct mixes on grass type, shade and drought tolerance, germination time, seeding rate, price per pound, and whether fertilizer is included.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with where you live and what the spot looks like. Everything else comes second.

1. Match the grass to your climate

  • Cool-season grasses (tall fescue, Kentucky bluegrass, perennial ryegrass, fine fescues) suit the north and the transition zone. Plant in early spring or early fall.
  • Warm-season grasses (bermudagrass, zoysia) suit the south and go in late spring or early summer. They need full sun.
  • A tall fescue mix is the usual choice in the transition zone and hot, humid southern lawns where cool-season grass is still wanted.

2. Measure the sun

Watch the spot over a day. Full sun is 6 to 8 or more hours; moderate shade is 4 to 6 hours; heavy shade is under 4. A sun and shade mix covers a lawn with both; pure sun grasses like bermudagrass fail in shade, and shade mixes thin out in open sun.

3. Decide what you are doing

  • New lawn: the highest seeding rate, plus soil preparation.
  • Overseeding: about a third of the new-lawn rate in many products.
  • Patching: a patch product with mulch costs far more per square foot but holds seed in place.

4. Compare the real cost

Bag prices mislead because bags differ in size and seeding rate. Use price per pound times the pounds per 1,000 sq ft for your project, and note that larger bags are usually cheaper per pound. Seed with a fertilizer coating saves a step but you pay for the coating; plain seed plus a separate starter fertilizer can cost less.

5. Check the label

Look for the germination percentage, weed seed content, and the test date on the bag, and buy seed that was tested this year. Ratings such as drought or shade tolerance are the maker's own and are not comparable between brands, so use them to tell one product from another within a brand.

6. Care matters most

Keep the top inch of soil moist until the seed sprouts and the new grass is a few inches tall. Most failed seedings come from uneven watering or planting out of season, not from the bag.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price per lb
$4/lb
Not stated
$6.66/lb
$12.57/lb
Not stated
$6.66/lb
$6.66/lb
$2.75/lb
$9.79/lb
$9.37/lb
$8.57/lb
$6.93/lb
$11.66/lb
$7.50/lb
$8.33/lb
$11.25/lb
$16/lb
$13.10/lb
$6.80/lb
$5.08/lb
$5.20/lb
$10/lb
⠿
Smallest bag
3 lb
3 lb
3 lb
1.75 lb
3 lb
3 lb
3 lb
3 lb
2.4 lb
2.4 lb
2.4 lb
3.75 lb
2.4 lb
4 lb
2.4 lb
2.4 lb
1 lb
5 lb
5 lb
25 lb
25 lb
5 lb
⠿
Grass type
Tall fescue, ryegrass, bluegrass, fine fescue
Tall fescue
Not stated
Bermudagrass
Kentucky bluegrass
Perennial ryegrass
Tall fescue, ryegrass, Kentucky bluegrass
Turf-type tall fescue
Bluegrass, ryegrass, fine fescues
Bluegrass, ryegrass, fine fescues
Tall fescue
Tall fescue
Kentucky bluegrass, perennial ryegrass
Tall fescue, Kentucky bluegrass
Tall fescue
Kentucky bluegrass
Bermudagrass
Zoysiagrass
Chewings fescue, perennial ryegrass
Bluegrass, ryegrass, chewings fescue
Mostly tall fescue, with bluegrass, ryegrass
Fine fescues, bluegrass, ryegrass
⠿
Climate
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season, southern US
Cool-season, most regions
Warm-season, southern US
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season (temporary on warm-season lawns)
Cool-season, northeast US
Cool-season, northern and transition zone
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season, transition zone
Cool-season, transition zone
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season, northern US
Cool-season, southern US
Cool-season, northern US
Warm-season, southern US
Warm-season, southern US
Cool-season, northern and transition zone
Cool-season, northern and transition zone
Cool-season, transition zone
Cool-season, northern and transition zone
⠿
Light conditions
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
2-6 hours of daily sun
8+ hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
Full sun to dense shade
Mix of sun and shade
Not stated
Full sun to dense shade
Full sun and light shade
Not stated
Full sun and partial shade
Sunny areas
Full sun
Full sun and light shade
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
4-6 hours of daily sun
4+ hours of daily sun
⠿
Shade tolerance
Good
Good
Excellent
Inadequate
Good
Moderate
Good
Moderate
4 out of 5
Not stated
Not stated
Works in dense shade
Light shade
Not stated
Partial shade
Not stated
Poor
Light shade
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate to dense
⠿
Drought tolerance
Very good
Very good
Good
Very good
Good
Good
Very good
Very good
3 out of 5 (moderate)
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Medium to high
Deep-rooted, water-saving mix
Medium to high
Not stated
Not stated
Medium to high
Good (chewings fescue)
Great once established
Handles drought stress
Drought-tolerant fescues
⠿
Traffic tolerance
Good
Good
Good
Excellent
Excellent
Excellent
Good
Excellent
4 out of 5 (durability)
Not stated
Not stated
Works in high-traffic areas
Medium to high
Not stated
High
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Withstands heavy foot traffic
Great once established
Not stated
Extra durability from bluegrass
⠿
Germination time
8-21 days
8-21 days
8-16 days
10-14 days
15-30 days
8-14 days
8-14 days
8-16 days
6-12 days
6-12 days
Not stated
7-14 days
Not stated
6-10 days
Not stated
14-21 days
Not stated
10-21 days
7-28 days
7-28 days
7-28 days
14-21 days
⠿
New lawn seeding rate
9 lb/1000 sq ft
12 lb/1000 sq ft
8 lb/1000 sq ft
3.5 lb/1000 sq ft
3 lb/1000 sq ft
12 lb/1000 sq ft
9 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
7.5 lb/1000 sq ft
6.7 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
Doesn't apply
6.7 lb/1000 sq ft
6 lb/1000 sq ft
12 lb/1000 sq ft
4.5 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
7.5 lb/1000 sq ft
5 lb/1000 sq ft to 10
5 lb/1000 sq ft to 10
6 lb/1000 sq ft to 7
8 lb/1000 sq ft
⠿
Overseeding rate
3 lb/1000 sq ft
4 lb/1000 sq ft
4 lb/1000 sq ft
1.75 lb/1000 sq ft
1.5 lb/1000 sq ft
4 lb/1000 sq ft
3 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
2.5 lb/1000 sq ft
2 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
Doesn't apply
2.2 lb/1000 sq ft
2 lb/1000 sq ft
4 lb/1000 sq ft
1.5 lb/1000 sq ft
Not stated
2.5 lb/1000 sq ft
3 lb/1000 sq ft to 5
3 lb/1000 sq ft to 5
5 lb/1000 sq ft
5 lb/1000 sq ft
⠿
Includes fertilizer
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Best planting season
Early spring or early fall
Early spring or early fall
Early spring or early fall
Spring or early summer
Early spring or early fall
Early spring or early fall
Early spring or early fall
Early spring or early fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or early summer
Late spring or early summer
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
Spring or fall
⠿
Use
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
Patching bare spots
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding
New lawn or overseeding

Why these features matter

  • Price per lb ($/lb)

    Bags range from about $3 to $16 a pound. Compare the cost of covering your lawn, not just the bag price, since seeding rates differ.

  • Smallest bag (lb)

    Small lawns and patches need a small bag; seed left over after opening loses germination over time.

  • Grass type

    Species decide climate fit, shade and drought tolerance, and how fast it grows in.

  • Climate

    A cool-season seed in a hot southern lawn, or bermudagrass in the north, will fail.

  • Light conditions

    Match it to your yard: full-sun grass dies in shade, and shade mixes thin out in open sun.

  • Shade tolerance

    Under trees and north of buildings this matters more than almost anything else.

  • Drought tolerance

    Drought-tolerant seed saves watering, but all grass needs steady water until established.

  • Traffic tolerance

    Matters most for play areas and lawns with dogs.

  • Germination time

    Faster sprouting means less time for weeds and washouts; slow grasses need more patience and watering.

  • New lawn seeding rate (lb/1000 sq ft)

    Together with price per lb, this sets what your lawn costs to seed.

  • Overseeding rate (lb/1000 sq ft)

    Overseeding is the most common use; this tells you how much to buy.

  • Includes fertilizer

    Built-in fertilizer saves a step but adds cost; coated seed also weighs more per bag.

  • Best planting season

    Planting out of season is the commonest reason new grass fails.

  • Use

    A patch product is far costlier per square foot than seed for a whole lawn.

About the products

  • Smart Seed Sun & Shade · Pennington

    Northern seed and fertilizer coating mix for lawns with sun and moderate shade. Very good drought tolerance once established; sold in 3, 7 and 20 lb bags.

  • Smart Seed Sun & Shade (Southern) · Pennington

    Tall fescue mix with fertilizer coating for sun and moderate shade in hot, humid southern lawns. Needs a heavier seeding rate than the northern mix.

  • Smart Seed Dense Shade · Pennington

    Seed and fertilizer mix for heavy shade, as little as 2 to 6 hours of sun. Weak in full sun, so it is not the pick for open lawns.

  • Smart Seed Bermudagrass Mix · Pennington

    Warm-season bermudagrass with fertilizer coating for full sun (8+ hours). Excellent traffic tolerance, but shade tolerance is rated inadequate.

  • Smart Seed Kentucky Bluegrass Mix · Pennington

    Kentucky bluegrass blend with fertilizer coating for a dense, durable northern lawn. Slowest to germinate (15 to 30 days) of the Pennington mixes.

  • Smart Seed Perennial Ryegrass · Pennington

    Single-species ryegrass for fast cover: germinates in 8 to 14 days and also works as a temporary winter overseed on warm-season lawns.

  • Smart Seed Northeast Grass Mix · Pennington

    Tall fescue, perennial ryegrass and Kentucky bluegrass mix built for northeastern winters and humid summers.

  • The Rebels Tall Fescue · Pennington

    Turf-type tall fescue for northern and transition lawns with deep roots and excellent drought and traffic tolerance. Plain seed with no fertilizer coating, and the lowest price per pound here.

  • Turf Builder Grass Seed Sun & Shade Mix · Scotts

    Seed, fertilizer and soil improver in one bag, for lawns from full sun to dense shade. Moderate drought tolerance; seed is treated with a fungicide.

  • Turf Builder Rapid Grass Sun & Shade Mix · Scotts

    Seed plus a stronger 13-0-0 fertilizer coating for northern lawns with sun and shade; pricier per pound than the standard Sun & Shade mix.

  • Turf Builder Rapid Grass Tall Fescue Mix · Scotts

    Tall fescue seed with 9-0-0 fertilizer, made for transition-zone lawns; Scotts says it grows grass twice as fast as seed alone.

  • EZ Seed Patch & Repair Tall Fescue · Scotts

    Seed, expanding mulch and fertilizer for patching bare spots in tall fescue lawns, including dense shade, slopes and high-traffic areas. Not meant for whole-lawn seeding.

  • Turf Builder Grass Seed Sunny Mix · Scotts

    Kentucky bluegrass and perennial ryegrass with fertilizer for full sun and light shade; medium-to-high drought resistance.

  • Grass Seed Drought Tolerant Mix · Scotts

    Tall fescue and Kentucky bluegrass for northern lawns, with deep roots to save water. Plain seed, sold at the lowest per-pound Scotts price among full-lawn mixes.

  • Turf Builder Grass Seed Southern Gold Mix · Scotts

    Tall fescue for southern lawns, in full sun and partial shade, with fertilizer and soil improver; high durability.

  • Turf Builder Grass Seed Kentucky Bluegrass Mix · Scotts

    Elite Kentucky bluegrass with fertilizer for a thick, classic lawn in sunny areas. Slow to sprout (14 to 21 days) but spreads to fill gaps.

  • Turf Builder Rapid Grass Bermudagrass · Scotts

    Bermudagrass seed with 23-0-0 fertilizer for warm-season lawns in full sun; plant in spring or early summer.

  • Turf Builder Zoysia Grass Seed & Mulch · Scotts

    Zoysiagrass seed with mulch for warm-season lawns in full sun and light shade; plant late spring or early summer. Pricey per pound and slow to sprout.

  • Sun & Shade Grass Seed Mix · Hancock Seed

    Chewings fescue and perennial ryegrass sold raw (no coating or fertilizer) direct from the farm, down to 5 lb bags with free shipping.

  • Northeast/Midwest Lawn Seed Mix · Hancock Seed

    Low-maintenance Kentucky bluegrass, ryegrass and fescue mix for full sun to moderate shade in the northern states. Sold in 25 lb bags only.

  • Central States Lawn Seed Mix · Hancock Seed

    Mostly fescue mix for the transition zone, full sun to moderate shade, with low maintenance. Sold in 25 lb bags only.

  • Choice Shade Seed Mix · Hancock Seed

    Fine fescues, Kentucky bluegrass and ryegrass for moderate to dense shade, usable for new seeding, overseeding and patching.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons