Holiday pies

Compare classic and creative holiday pies by filling, flavor, texture, crust, recipe timing and storage. Images are AI-generated illustrations.

Last updated

How to choose

Choose a mix of flavors and textures: spiced custard, bright fruit, crunchy nuts and creamy chocolate or coconut. Fruit pies can be tart, while nut and cream pies tend to be rich.

Timings, crusts and storage instructions refer to the linked example recipes, not every version of the pie. Allow extra cooling or chilling time when the recipe says to, and check the actual recipe or bakery label for allergens. Refrigerate perishable custard and cream pies promptly.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Links
โ ฟ
Main filling
Pumpkin purรฉe
Pecans and syrup
Apples
Sweet potatoes
Sour cherries
Chocolate and whipped cream
Key lime custard
Spiced fruit, nuts and brandy
Cranberry and cream
Lemon custard
Coconut and pastry cream
Buttermilk custard
Lemon, eggs and sugar
Fresh and cooked blueberries
Chocolate chips and pecans
Maple cream
Peanut butter and marshmallow
Bananas and pastry cream
โ ฟ
Flavor
Spiced, rich
Sweet, nutty
Cinnamon and apple
Rich
Tart, tangy
Rich chocolate
Tart and sweet
Rich, sweet and spiced
Tart, tangy and sweet
Sweet, tart lemon
Sweet coconut
Sweet, tangy
Sweet lemon
Sweet blueberry
Chocolate, nutty
Sweet maple
Sweet and salty
Banana and cream
โ ฟ
Texture
Smooth custard
Crunchy nuts, silky filling
Thinly sliced apples
Creamy, smooth
Juicy fruit
Light, mousse-like
Silky custard
Soft fruit, crunchy nuts
Creamy
Soft filling, airy meringue
Creamy, chewy coconut
Soft custard
Soft, set filling
Soft and fresh berries
Crunchy pecans, soft filling
Silky cream
Light and fluffy
Soft fruit, creamy filling
โ ฟ
Crust
Single pastry crust
Single pastry crust
Double pastry crust
Single pastry crust
Double pastry, lattice top
Graham cracker crust
Graham cracker crust
Double pastry crust
Cranberry pastry crust
Single oil pastry crust
Graham cracker crust
Single pastry crust
Single pastry crust
Pastry crust with cutouts
Single pastry crust
Single pastry crust
Graham cracker crust
Single pastry crust
โ ฟ
Hands on time
30 min
20 min
30 min
30 min
35 min
30 min
15 min
25 min
60 min
25 min
20 min
25 min
25 min
60 min
25 min
30 min
25 min
30 min
โ ฟ
Total recipe time
75 min
90 min
105 min
150 min
80 min
98 min
55 min
850 min
440 min
50 min
165 min
133 min
70 min
300 min
95 min
510 min
690 min
90 min
โ ฟ
Leftover storage
Refrigerate
Refrigerate
Not stated
Not stated
Refrigerate
Not stated
Refrigerate
Not stated
Not stated
Refrigerate
Refrigerate
Not stated
Refrigerate
Refrigerate
Not stated
Refrigerate
Not stated
Not stated
โ ฟ
Bake time
45 min to 50 min
70 min
45 min to 50 min
Not stated
40 min to 45 min
8 min to 10 min
40 min
Not stated
Not stated
20 min to 25 min
8 min to 10 min
44 min to 48 min
45 min to 50 min
35 min to 50 min
40 min to 50 min
25 min to 35 min
20 min to 25 min
30 min to 35 min
โ ฟ
Serving preparation
Cool before slicing
Serve with vanilla ice cream or whipped cream
Wait about 1 hour before cutting and serving
Not stated
Cool before slicing
Chill before serving
Chill before serving
Cool before slicing
Chill before serving
Cool before slicing
Chill before serving
Not stated
Cool before slicing
Chill before serving
Cool before slicing
Chill before serving
Chill before serving
Chill before serving

Why these features matter

  • Main filling

    The filling is the starting point for flavor and dietary preferences.

  • Flavor

    Choose a flavor to suit the rest of your dessert table.

  • Texture

    A mix of textures can offer guests more variety.

  • Crust

    The crust changes the texture and the effort involved.

  • Hands on time (min)

    Plan the time you need to be in the kitchen.

  • Total recipe time (min)

    Useful for scheduling, but check chilling and cooling instructions separately.

  • Leftover storage

    Custard and cream pies generally need refrigeration; follow your own recipe or label.

  • Bake time (min)

    Oven time matters when several holiday dishes need the oven.

  • Serving preparation

    Cooling and chilling affect how early to start and whether the filling slices cleanly.

About the products

  • Pumpkin pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Pecan pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Apple pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Sweet potato pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Cherry pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Chocolate cream pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Key lime pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Mincemeat pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Cranberry pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Lemon meringue pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Coconut cream pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Buttermilk pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Lemon chess pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Blueberry pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Chocolate pecan pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Maple cream pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Peanut butter pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

  • Banana cream pie

    Compare this style using the linked representative recipe; other recipes vary.

Suggest a change

Youโ€™ll sign in or create a free account to send it. Weโ€™ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons