Sugar substitutes

Sugar substitutes range from sucralose and aspartame packets to erythritol, monk fruit, stevia and allulose blends. This grid compares eight popular US brands on what they contain, how they measure against sugar, and what makers say about baking.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with why you want a substitute: cutting calories, avoiding blood sugar spikes, following keto, or baking.

Check the ingredients first

  • Bulking agents. Packets such as Splenda and Equal are mostly dextrose and maltodextrin, which add a small amount of carbohydrate. Erythritol and allulose blends use sugar alcohols or a rare sugar instead.
  • Ingredients you want to avoid. Each ingredient has its own row (sucralose, aspartame, erythritol, stevia, monk fruit), so rule out what you dislike before comparing anything else.

Match it to how you use it

  • For coffee and tea, sweetness per packet and the form matter most.
  • For baking, look for a product that measures like sugar and whether the maker says it browns, and remember that intense sweeteners do not add the bulk of sugar.

Before you buy

Read the label on the exact pack you buy: blends are reformulated, and a brand often sells several products with different ingredients. If you have diabetes or another condition, ask your clinician which sweeteners suit you.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Sweetening ingredients
Dextrose, maltodextrin, sucralose
Erythritol, monk fruit extract
Dextrose with maltodextrin, aspartame, acesulfame potassium
Saccharin, dextrose
Erythritol, monk fruit extract
Erythritol, allulose, natural flavor, xanthan gum
Allulose
Organic allulose, organic stevia leaf extract, organic natural flavor
Erythritol, stevia leaf extract, natural flavors
Dextrose, stevia extract
Dextrose, monk fruit extract
⠿
Sweetness vs sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1:1 with sugar by volume
1:1 with sugar by volume
1 1/3 cups = 1 cup sugar
2x sweeter than table sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
⠿
Sucralose
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Aspartame
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Erythritol
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
No
⠿
Stevia extract
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
⠿
Monk fruit extract
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
⠿
Maltodextrin or dextrose
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
⠿
Baking guidance
Packet conversion chart; not for recipes where sugar is an ingredient
Packet conversion chart; cup-for-cup baking is the Sweet Complete line
No sugar bulk or browning; best where others give bulk
Keeps sweetness when heated; used in baking
Great for cooking and baking; use in cookies, cakes, sauces
Browns and caramelizes; excellent baking
Ideal for cakes, muffins, quick breads
Holds up in the oven; cookies, cakes, muffins
Packet conversion chart; cup-for-cup baking is the Sweet Complete line
Packet conversion chart; not for recipes where sugar is an ingredient
Packet conversion chart; not for recipes where sugar is an ingredient
⠿
Forms sold
Packets, 50 to 1000 count
Packets
Packets, 50 to 1000 count
Packets, 8 oz bulk box, 8 fl oz liquid
Bulk 8.29 oz to 5 lb; 3 g packets
Granular, 12 oz and 48 oz
Granulated, 12 oz; liquid sold separately
Granulated, 12 oz to 2.5 lb
Packets, 30 to 1000 count
Packets, 50 to 1000 count
Packets, 80 count
⠿
Gluten free
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
⠿
Allulose
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
⠿
Saccharin
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Acesulfame potassium
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No

Why these features matter

  • Sweetening ingredients

    Everything else follows from the ingredient list, and blends differ widely between brands.

  • Sweetness vs sugar

    Tells you how much to use; a 1:1 measure is easier to bake with.

    1 packet = 2 tsp sugar
    : Each packet sweetens a cup of coffee like two teaspoons of sugar. Easy for drinks; packets do not replace sugar cup for cup in recipes.
    Measures like sugar
    : Use the same volume as sugar, which makes swapping into recipes simple.
  • Sucralose

    Some buyers avoid sucralose; others prefer it for heat stability and zero calories.

  • Aspartame

    Avoided by people with phenylketonuria and by buyers who dislike it; it also loses sweetness with heat.

  • Erythritol

    A sugar alcohol that adds bulk for baking but that some buyers avoid or find cooling or upsetting to digest.

  • Stevia extract

    A plant-derived sweetener some buyers prefer, though some notice an aftertaste.

  • Monk fruit extract

    A fruit-derived sweetener often chosen as a natural option.

  • Maltodextrin or dextrose

    These carbohydrate fillers add a little sugar-like carbohydrate and matter to strict low-carb or diabetic diets.

  • Baking guidance

    Intense sweeteners lack sugar's bulk and browning, so makers' own advice shows how far you can swap.

  • Forms sold

    Packets suit drinks and travel; bulk granulated suits baking.

  • Gluten free

    Important for celiac disease and gluten sensitivity.

  • Allulose

    Allulose is a rare sugar that bakes and browns like sugar; some buyers seek it out, others watch for digestive effects.

  • Saccharin

    Saccharin is the oldest artificial sweetener; some buyers avoid it for its aftertaste or reputation.

  • Acesulfame potassium

    Ace-K is often blended with aspartame; some buyers avoid it.

About the products

  • Splenda Sweetener Packets · Splenda

    Sucralose packets bulked with dextrose and maltodextrin. A familiar zero-calorie pick for coffee and tea; the maker advises against direct substitution where sugar is a recipe ingredient.

  • Truvia Original Monk Fruit Packets · Truvia

    Erythritol with monk fruit extract in packets. Truvia also sells a stevia version with different ingredients.

  • Equal Original · Equal

    Aspartame and acesulfame potassium packets. Maker says it lacks sugar's bulk and browning, so it suits drinks and recipes where other ingredients give bulk.

  • Sweet'N Low Packets · Sweet'N Low

    Saccharin-based packets, also sold as bulk and liquid. The maker says it keeps its sweetness when heated.

  • Lakanto Classic Monkfruit Sweetener · Lakanto

    Erythritol with monk fruit extract that measures 1:1 like sugar, aimed at keto baking.

  • Swerve Granular · Swerve

    Erythritol and allulose blend that measures like sugar; the maker says it browns and caramelizes.

  • Wholesome Allulose Granulated · Wholesome Sweeteners

    Single-ingredient allulose. About 1 1/3 cups replace 1 cup of sugar, so it is less sweet by volume.

  • Organic Granular Stevia Allulose Blend · Pyure

    Organic allulose with stevia leaf extract, erythritol free, about twice as sweet as table sugar.

  • Truvia Stevia Leaf Packets · Truvia

    The original Truvia: erythritol with stevia leaf extract in packets. Truvia also sells a monk fruit version with different ingredients.

  • Splenda Stevia Sweetener Packets · Splenda

    Stevia extract on a dextrose carrier in packets, for people who want a stevia-based Splenda instead of the sucralose original.

  • Splenda Monk Fruit Sweetener Packets · Splenda

    Monk fruit extract on a dextrose carrier in packets, for coffee, tea and cereal. Sold in 80 count boxes.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons