Night guards and teeth grinding mouthguards

A night guard is a thin plastic cover for your upper or lower teeth that takes the wear from grinding or clenching (bruxism) while you sleep. This grid compares 9 night guards you can buy in the US without a dentist visit: boil-and-bite and no-boil guards from drugstores, and custom guards made in a lab from a home impression. The choices come down to price, how well it fits, how thick and hard it is, how long it lasts, and what happens if it does not work for you.

Last updated

How to choose

A night guard protects your teeth; it does not stop grinding or treat the cause. If you have jaw pain, clicking or locking, headaches, loose teeth, dental work such as implants, braces or dentures, or you are under 18, see a dentist before choosing one: the makers of the off-the-shelf guards here list several of these as reasons not to use them.

Pick the type first

  • Ready-to-wear disposables (Plackers Grind No More) cost the least and need no fitting, so they suit a trial or travel. Each lasts up to about 3 nights.
  • No-boil adjustable guards (SleepRight Ultra-Comfort, DenTek Ultimate) use bite pads you shift to fit; they are smaller and less bulky than full-coverage guards.
  • Boil-and-bite guards (DenTek Professional-Fit and SleepRight ProRx) are softened in hot water and bitten into shape. They cost about $15 to $25 and are full-coverage, but a poor mold means a poor fit.
  • Custom guards (JS Dental Lab, Pro Teeth Guard) are made in a lab from the impression you take at home and mail back. They cost about $160 to $220 and take weeks, but fit your teeth and come with longer warranties.

Compare what matters

  • Hardness and thickness: a hard guard resists heavy grinding but feels bulkier; soft or hybrid guards are more comfortable but may wear through sooner. Thickness is stated mostly by the custom makers.
  • Guarantee and warranty: a return window of 30 to 365 days and a 6-month to 2-year replacement warranty reduce your risk; check what proof of purchase the maker requires.
  • Full cost: prices are for different counts; a disposable 16-pack and a single custom guard are not the same thing. Guards wear out, so factor in replacement.

Wear a new guard for a few nights and stop if it causes pain or changes your bite. Clean it as the maker directs and check it for wear.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$15.78
$21.79
$24.34
$18.98
$19.88
$159
$159
$199.99
$219.99
⠿
Type
Boil-and-bite
Boil-and-bite
Adjustable, no boil
Boil-and-bite (lower-temperature mold)
Ready-to-wear, disposable
Custom, mail-in impression
Custom, mail-in impression
Custom, mail-in impression
Custom, mail-in impression
⠿
Fit process
Boil 75 seconds, bite down to mold
Heat, shape and wear with the SmartFit tray
Slide the bite pads; heat-sensitive band adapts
Warm to 150°F, mold with molar guides
None; wear as it comes
Home putty impression, mailed back in prepaid mailer
Home putty impression, mailed back in prepaid mailer
Home impression kit, mailed back to the lab
Home impression kit, mailed back to the lab
⠿
Coverage
Full coverage
Bite pads, flex band behind front teeth
Two bite pads between the molars
Full coverage
Bite plates, not full arch
Full coverage
Full coverage
Full coverage
Full coverage
⠿
Arch
Upper
Upper
Upper or lower (pads between molars)
Upper
Upper or lower
Upper or lower (choose)
Upper or lower (choose)
Upper or lower (choose)
Upper or lower (choose)
⠿
Material
EVA, dual layer
BPA-free high-performance plastic (type not named)
Plastic with a heat-sensitive band
Moldable thermoplastic
Soft, shock-absorbing
Hard outer layer, soft inner layer
All-hard material
Dual-laminate: hard outside, soft inside
Hard acrylic (elasticized acrylic)
⠿
Thickness
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
3 mm
3 mm
approx 2 mm
approx 1.5 mm
⠿
Guards included
1 guards
1 guards
1 guards
1 guards
16 guards
1 guards
1 guards
1 guards
1 guards
⠿
Money back guarantee
30 days
30 days
45 days
45 days
Not stated
365 days
365 days
60 days
60 days
⠿
Warranty or protection
6 months protection guarantee
6 months protection guarantee
1 year limited warranty, one replacement
2 year limited warranty
None; each disposable guard lasts up to 3 nights
1 year warranty
1 year warranty
1 year warranty, free replacement if it cracks
1 year warranty, free replacement if it cracks
⠿
Lead time
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
About 10 business days after the impression arrives
About 10 business days after the impression arrives
3 to 4 weeks from ordering
3 to 4 weeks from ordering
⠿
BPA free
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Case included
Not stated
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    A guard costs from under $10 for a disposable pack to $150 to $220 for a lab-made custom guard; compare it with how long each lasts.

  • Type

    Custom guards from your own impression fit best and last longest; boil-and-bite and ready-to-wear guards are cheaper but fit less precisely.

  • Fit process

    A poor home fit makes a guard uncomfortable or ineffective, so know how much effort and risk the fitting involves.

  • Coverage

    Full coverage spreads the force across all the teeth; partial guards are smaller and easier to breathe around but protect less of the arch.

  • Arch

    Most people wear an upper guard; a lower guard can feel less bulky or suit people with a gag reflex, and dentists often advise which.

  • Material

    Hard materials resist heavy grinding and staining; soft ones are more comfortable but wear through faster.

  • Thickness (mm)

    Thicker guards last longer under heavy grinding but feel bulkier, which can affect sleep and breathing.

  • Guards included (guards)

    Disposable and boil-and-bite packs include spares; custom guards are one per arch ordered.

  • Money back guarantee (days)

    A fitted guard can feel wrong at first, so a long return window lowers your risk, especially for a custom guard.

  • Warranty or protection

    Tells you how long the maker expects it to hold up; grinders can wear through a guard in months.

  • Lead time

    Custom guards take weeks because you mail impressions to a lab; plan for it if you need protection now.

  • BPA free

    BPA is a chemical some buyers avoid in anything held in the mouth all night.

  • Case included

    A guard lives in a case during the day; if none is included, add a few dollars.

About the products

  • DenTek Professional-Fit Dental Guard · DenTek

    Boil-and-bite guard with a soft upper layer and a hard grind-shield layer for the upper teeth; the maker backs it with a 6-month protection guarantee.

  • DenTek Ultimate Dental Guard · DenTek

    Slimmer boil-and-bite guard with cushioned bite pads and a flex band behind the front teeth for airflow, for people who dislike full-coverage guards. Includes a case.

  • SleepRight Ultra-Comfort Dental Guard · SleepRight

    No-boil guard with two adjustable bite pads that sit between the molars and a heat-sensitive band; ready to wear from the box.

  • SleepRight ProRx Custom-Fit Dental Guard · SleepRight

    Full-coverage guard that you mold at home after warming it to 150°F, a lower temperature than boiling water; includes a case and a 2-year limited warranty.

  • Grind No More Dental Guard · Plackers

    One-size, disposable guards you wear as they come, upper or lower, for up to 3 nights each; a low-cost way to try a guard before paying for a custom one.

  • JS Dental Lab Hybrid Shield Night Guard · JS Dental Lab

    Custom guard made from a mailed-in impression: 3 mm, with a firm outer layer and a soft inner layer, for light to moderate grinding. Backed by a 365-day return window and a 1-year warranty.

  • JS Dental Lab Hard Shield Night Guard · JS Dental Lab

    Custom 3 mm all-hard guard from a mailed-in impression, aimed at heavy grinders who wear through softer guards.

  • Pro Teeth Guard Hybrid Night Guard · Pro Teeth Guard

    Custom dual-laminate guard (hard outside, soft inside, about 2 mm) for moderate grinding; the maker's most popular. 60-day money-back guarantee and 1-year warranty.

  • Pro Teeth Guard Hard Night Guard · Pro Teeth Guard

    Custom hard acrylic guard, about 1.5 mm, for heavy to severe grinding; 60-day money-back guarantee and 1-year warranty.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons