Sugar-free gum

Sugar-free gum covers the big stick and bottle brands (Trident, Orbit, Extra, 5, Dentyne, Ice Breakers, Mentos) and a smaller group of xylitol-first brands (Spry, PUR, Simply Gum, Epic). They all skip sugar, but they differ in what replaces it, what else is in the gum, how much a piece costs, and whether the ADA Seal of Acceptance applies. This grid compares the practical differences for a US shopper: sweeteners, xylitol, price per piece, ingredients such as aspartame, dyes, BHT and gelatin, flavors, and pack size.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with why you chew. For fresh breath on the go, price per piece, flavor and a pocket-sized pack matter most. For teeth, look for the ADA Seal of Acceptance, which rests on the act of chewing sugar-free gum for 20 minutes after eating, and for xylitol high in the ingredient list.

Check the ingredient list for deal-breakers

  • Aspartame: most mainstream gums use it and carry a phenylketonurics warning. Xylitol-only brands skip it.
  • Sorbitol and other sugar alcohols: chewed in large amounts they can cause gas or a laxative effect.
  • Dyes, BHT and gelatin: check them if you avoid artificial colors, preservatives, or animal ingredients. Some candy-shell gums contain gelatin.
  • Gum base: almost every brand just says gum base. Simply Gum is the one here that names a chicle tree-sap base.

Look at xylitol honestly

Xylitol first on the label is a good sign, but only Epic states a dose per piece here. A gum with xylitol at the very end of the list has little. If cavity prevention is the goal, the ADA Seal and a xylitol-only list are two different routes; pick one you trust.

Compare cost per piece, not per pack

Packs range from 14 sticks to 100 pieces. Divide price by pieces, and remember multipacks and online bundles change the math. The brand gums are generally cheapest per piece; xylitol-only brands cost more.

Before you buy

  • Pick the flavor you will actually finish: the ingredients below are for one representative flavor and others can differ.
  • Ingredients and recipes change, so read the label on the pack in your hand.
  • Gum is not a replacement for brushing and flossing, and very small children should not chew it.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price per piece
9.4 cents
10.9 cents
13 cents
25 cents
12.4 cents
12.7 cents
8.3 cents
12.1 cents
8.5 cents
12 cents
9.1 cents
21.1 cents
12.6 cents
⠿
Main sweeteners
Sorbitol, xylitol, aspartame, sucralose
Xylitol, sorbitol, aspartame, maltitol
Sorbitol, aspartame, acesulfame K, trace xylitol
Xylitol, aspartame, sorbitol, acesulfame K
Sorbitol, aspartame, acesulfame K
Sorbitol, aspartame, acesulfame K
Sorbitol, maltitol, aspartame, sucralose
Xylitol, maltitol, aspartame, neotame
Xylitol, sorbitol, maltitol, aspartame, sucralose
Xylitol only
Xylitol only
Xylitol only
Xylitol only
⠿
Xylitol in ingredients
Third listed
First listed
Under 2%
First listed
None
None
None
First listed
First listed
Only sweetener
Only sweetener
Only sweetener
Only sweetener
⠿
Pieces per pack
14 pieces
40 pieces
14 pieces
40 pieces
15 pieces
15 pieces
16 pieces
40 pieces
50 pieces
100 pieces
55 pieces
15 pieces
50 pieces
⠿
Price per pack
$1.32
$4.37
$1.82
$9.99
$1.86
$1.90
$1.32
$4.82
$4.27
$11.99
$4.99
$3.17
$6.29
⠿
Xylitol per piece
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
1.06 g
⠿
Contains aspartame
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Contains sorbitol
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
ADA Seal of Acceptance
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Added colors
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
BHT preservative
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Gelatin
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
⠿
Gum base
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Gum base, type not stated
Chicle tree sap, plastic-free
Gum base, type not stated
⠿
Flavors
4 flavors
5 flavors
8 flavors
3 flavors
5 flavors
4 flavors
3 flavors
6 flavors
8 flavors
5 flavors
4 flavors
3 flavors
8 flavors
⠿
Pack format
Stick pack
Bottle
Stick pack
Bottle
Stick pack
Stick pack
Blister pack
Bottle
Bottle
Bottle
Pouch
Pouch
Bottle

Why these features matter

  • Price per piece (cents)

    The fairest way to compare gum, because packs range from 14 sticks to 100 pieces. Heavy chewers should care most; occasional chewers care more about the pack price.

  • Main sweeteners

    Sweeteners decide the aftertaste, the laxative risk of sugar alcohols, and whether the gum suits people avoiding aspartame.

  • Xylitol in ingredients

    Xylitol is the sugar alcohol most associated with cavity prevention, but only when the dose is meaningful. A trace near the end of the list does little.

  • Pieces per pack (pieces)

    Pack size changes both cost and convenience: a 14-piece pack fits a pocket; a 100-piece container sits on a desk.

  • Price per pack ($)

    What you pay at the register, for budget planning.

  • Xylitol per piece (g)

    Studies behind xylitol's dental benefit use several grams a day, so a stated dose per piece lets you see whether it is plausible. Most makers do not publish it.

  • Contains aspartame

    Some people avoid aspartame by preference, and anyone with phenylketonuria must.

  • Contains sorbitol

    Sorbitol and other sugar alcohols can cause gas or a laxative effect when chewed in large amounts.

  • ADA Seal of Acceptance

    The Seal means the ADA reviewed evidence that chewing the gum after eating helps prevent cavities.

  • Added colors

    Shoppers avoiding dyes, or buying for kids, often check this.

  • BHT preservative

    BHT is a common gum-base preservative that some shoppers prefer to avoid.

  • Gelatin

    Gelatin is animal-derived, so it matters for vegetarians and vegans.

  • Gum base

    Most gum bases are synthetic polymers; a few brands use chicle tree sap and market it as plastic-free.

  • Flavors (flavors)

    More flavors helps if you chew to taste, not just to freshen breath.

  • Pack format

    Bottles and tubs suit a desk or car; sticks and blister packs slip into a pocket.

About the products

  • Trident · Perfetti Van Melle

    The classic stick-pack sugar-free gum, and an ADA Seal holder. Xylitol is the third ingredient, but it still relies on sorbitol and aspartame and carries BHT. Cheapest per piece of the big brands.

  • Trident Vibes · Perfetti Van Melle

    Candy-shell square pieces sold in a 40-piece bottle, with xylitol listed first. The shell uses artificial dyes and the pieces contain gelatin, so it is not vegetarian.

  • Orbit · Mars Wrigley

    Wrigley's mainstream mint and fruit stick gum in 14-piece packs. Sorbitol and aspartame sweeten it, with only a trace of xylitol; it is ADA Seal accepted.

  • Orbit White · Mars Wrigley

    Orbit's whitening line in a 40-piece bottle (priced here from Walmart's single bottle). Xylitol is the first ingredient, and the maker markets it as helping reduce staining. Colored with Blue 1.

  • Extra · Mars Wrigley

    Long-lasting stick gum in a 15-stick pack, widely sold in multipacks. Sweetened with sorbitol and aspartame, with no xylitol and added colors in the spearmint.

  • 5 Gum · Mars Wrigley

    Wrigley's bold-flavor stick gum in a 15-stick pack. Sweetened with sorbitol and aspartame, no xylitol; the Cobalt peppermint is colored with Blue 1 Lake.

  • Dentyne Ice · Perfetti Van Melle

    Small icy cubes in a 16-piece blister pack. Sweetened with sorbitol, maltitol and aspartame, with no xylitol, and colored with titanium dioxide. Priced here from Walmart's 3-pack.

  • Ice Breakers Ice Cubes · Hershey

    Square mint cubes in a 40-piece bottle, ADA Seal accepted, with xylitol as the first ingredient. Contains artificial colors, several artificial sweeteners and gelatin.

  • Mentos Pure Fresh · Perfetti Van Melle

    Xylitol-first bottled gum with a hard-shell coating, ADA Seal accepted and sold in 50 to 120 piece bottles. It also uses aspartame, sorbitol and BHT.

  • Spry Xylitol Gum · Xlear

    Xylitol-only gum with no aspartame, sorbitol, BHT or artificial colors, in a 100-piece container. Costs more per piece than the big brands and does not carry the ADA Seal.

  • PUR Gum · PUR Gum

    Xylitol-only gum with a short ingredient list (gum base, gum arabic, natural flavors, carnauba wax, tocopherols) and vegan, aspartame-free claims. Sold in 55-piece packs.

  • Simply Gum · Simply Gum

    Plastic-free gum on a chicle (tree sap) base, sweetened only with xylitol. Vegan and kosher, in 15-piece packs sold mainly in 6-packs. The priciest per piece here.

  • Epic Xylitol Gum · Epic Dental

    The dental-brand pick that states its xylitol dose: 1.06 g per piece, with xylitol the only sweetener. Vegan, with no aspartame, in a 50-piece bottle.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons