Dental chewing gum
Dental chewing gum means sugar-free gum that is either accepted by the American Dental Association (ADA) Seal program or built around xylitol, a sweetener that cavity-causing bacteria cannot use. The two routes are different. The ADA Seal rests on chewing sugar-free gum for 20 minutes after eating, and the Seal gums here (Trident, Orbit, Mentos, Ice Breakers) are mostly sweetened with sorbitol and aspartame. The xylitol brands (Spry, PUR, Epic, Xylichew, Simply Gum) use xylitol as the only sweetener and cost more per piece, but none carries the Seal. This grid compares both, with label facts: xylitol per piece where published, sweeteners, other ingredients, price per piece, and dog warnings. Gum does not replace brushing and flossing.
Last updated
How to choose
Start with what you want from the gum. If you want a gum a dental body has reviewed, look for the ADA Seal of Acceptance. The ADA says the Seal rests on its finding that chewing the gum for 20 minutes after eating stimulates saliva flow, and that gum is not a substitute for brushing twice a day with fluoride toothpaste and cleaning between teeth daily. If you want a xylitol-based gum, read the label for how much xylitol is in each piece, because the studies makers cite use several grams a day.
Two different routes
- ADA Seal gums (Trident, Orbit, Orbit White, Mentos Pure Fresh, Ice Breakers Ice Cubes here): easy to find and cheap per piece. Most mix sorbitol, aspartame and BHT; xylitol is only third in Trident and under 2% in Orbit, but first in Mentos, Ice Breakers and Orbit White. None publishes a xylitol dose.
- Xylitol-only gums (Spry, PUR, Epic, Xylichew, Simply Gum): xylitol is the only sweetener, no aspartame, and Epic, Xylichew and Spry print about 1 gram per piece. They cost roughly 12 to 21 cents a piece against 8 to 13 cents for the big brands, and none has the Seal.
Check the label
- Xylitol per piece: only a few makers state it. Count how many pieces you would chew a day against the dose you are aiming for, and do not assume more xylitol is always better: sugar alcohols can cause gas or a laxative effect in large amounts.
- Aspartame, dyes, BHT: common in the big brands, absent in the xylitol brands. People with phenylketonuria must avoid aspartame.
- Gum base: most labels just say gum base; Simply Gum names a chicle tree-sap base, and Epic says its synthetic base is biodegradable.
- Other actives: we did not find a fluoride or Recaldent (CPP-ACP) gum sold at major US retailers; the few extras here are calcium carbonate, sodium bicarbonate or green tea extract, and none is a proven treatment.
Keep pets safe
Xylitol is poisonous to dogs. Only Xylichew and Ice Breakers say so in what we found, so keep every pack out of a dog's reach whatever the label says, and call a vet at once if a dog eats gum.
Before you buy
- Compare price per piece, not price per pack: packs run from 14 sticks to 100 pieces.
- Ingredient lists are for one flavor and can change; read the pack in your hand.
- This grid reports what makers and the ADA state; it makes no medical claim. Ask your dentist about your own teeth, and keep brushing and flossing.
Answer
Browse the table. Filter to what matters.
Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.
Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.
Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it
| Feature | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ | ⠿ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
⠿
ADA Seal of Acceptance
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
⠿
Xylitol per piece
|
Doesn't apply
|
1 g
|
1 g
|
||||||||
|
⠿
Xylitol per serving
|
Doesn't apply
|
2 g per 2 pieces
|
2 g per 2 pieces
|
||||||||
|
⠿
Xylitol in ingredients
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Main sweeteners
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Other actives
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Gum base
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Price per piece
|
9.1 cents
|
12.6 cents
|
20 cents
|
21.1 cents
|
|||||||
|
⠿
Pieces per pack
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Price per pack
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Contains aspartame
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Added colors
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
BHT preservative
|
|||||||||||
|
⠿
Dog warning on label
|
Doesn't apply
|
||||||||||
|
⠿
Flavors
|
4 flavors
|
12+ flavors
|
5 flavors
|
2 flavors
|
|||||||
|
⠿
Sucralose
|
|
||||||||||
|
⠿
Soy lecithin
|
|
||||||||||
|
⠿
Artificial flavors
|
|
Why these features matter
-
ADA Seal of Acceptance
The Seal means the ADA reviewed the maker's safety and efficacy data and accepted that chewing the sugar-free gum for 20 minutes after eating helps prevent cavities. Gum never replaces brushing and flossing.
-
Xylitol per piece (g)
Studies behind xylitol's dental claims use several grams a day, so a stated dose per piece shows whether a day's chewing is plausible. Most big brands do not publish it; more is not always better because sugar alcohols can loosen the stomach.
-
Xylitol per serving (g)
Label servings differ (one piece or two), so the dose per serving is what you actually read on the pack. Compare it with the per-piece row.
-
Xylitol in ingredients
Xylitol is the sugar alcohol linked to cavity-prevention research, but only at a meaningful dose; a trace near the end of the list does little.
-
Main sweeteners
Sweeteners decide aftertaste, the laxative effect of sugar alcohols, and whether the gum suits people avoiding aspartame.
-
Other actives
Fluoride or CPP-ACP gums exist abroad, but none was found at major US retailers. A listed extra is not proof of a benefit, so weigh it as a minor point.
-
Gum base
Most gum bases are synthetic polymers; a few brands use chicle tree sap and market it as plastic-free.
-
Price per piece (cents)
The fairest way to compare gum, because packs run from 14 sticks to 100 pieces. Heavy chewers should care most.
-
Pieces per pack (pieces)
Pack size changes both cost and convenience: 14 sticks fit a pocket; 100 pieces sit on a desk.
-
Price per pack ($)
What you pay at the register, for budget planning.
-
Contains aspartame
Some people avoid aspartame by preference, and anyone with phenylketonuria must.
-
Added colors
Shoppers avoiding dyes, or buying for children, often check this.
-
BHT preservative
BHT is a common gum preservative that some shoppers prefer to avoid.
-
Dog warning on label
Xylitol is poisonous to dogs even in small amounts. Whatever the label says, keep gum out of a dog's reach.
-
Flavors (flavors)
More flavors helps if you chew to taste, not only to freshen breath.
-
Sucralose
Some buyers avoid sucralose, an artificial sweetener, by preference.
-
Soy lecithin
Soy is a common allergen and some buyers avoid it.
-
Artificial flavors
Some buyers avoid artificial flavors by preference.
About the products
-
Trident · Perfetti Van Melle
Classic stick gum with the ADA Seal for its sugar-free gum. Xylitol is only the third ingredient, after sorbitol, alongside aspartame and BHT; no xylitol dose is published. One of the cheapest per piece.
-
Orbit · Mars Wrigley
Wrigley's mainstream stick gum, also ADA Seal accepted. Sweetened mainly with sorbitol and aspartame; xylitol is listed under 2%, so it is a trace ingredient. Priced here from the 14-piece peppermint pack.
-
Orbit White · Mars Wrigley
Orbit's whitening line in a 40-piece bottle, ADA Seal accepted. Xylitol is the first ingredient, with aspartame, sorbitol and a Blue 1 color; the most expensive per piece here.
-
Mentos Pure Fresh · Perfetti Van Melle
Candy-shell bottled gum, ADA Seal accepted. Xylitol is listed first, but it is blended with sorbitol, maltitol syrup and aspartame, and colored; no xylitol dose is published. Cheapest per piece in this grid.
-
Ice Breakers Ice Cubes · Hershey
Cube-shaped bottle gum, ADA Seal accepted. Xylitol is listed first, blended with maltitol, mannitol and four other sweeteners, plus artificial color and gelatin. Hershey's own FAQ warns xylitol is not safe for pets.
-
Extra · Mars Wrigley
Wrigley's best-selling stick gum, sold here as a contrast: sugar-free but with no xylitol and no ADA Seal. Sweetened with sorbitol and aspartame, with added color and BHT.
-
Spry Xylitol Gum · Xlear
Xylitol-only gum in a 100-piece container, with about 0.9 g of xylitol a piece on retailer labels (Xlear's own label image rounds to 1 g). No aspartame, dyes or BHT; no ADA Seal.
-
PUR Gum · PUR Gum
Xylitol-only gum in a 55-piece bag, vegan and aspartame-free with a short ingredient list. The label serving is two pieces with 2 g of xylitol. Priced at Walmart's own shelf price.
-
Epic Xylitol Gum · Epic Dental
The dental-brand pick that states its dose: 1.06 g of xylitol per piece, xylitol as the only sweetener, in a 50-piece bottle. Sold direct, with a satisfaction guarantee.
-
Xylichew · Xylichew
Birch-xylitol gum in 50-piece bags with 1 g of xylitol per piece on the label and a 'Not for pets!' warning. No aspartame; made in the USA. No ADA Seal.
-
Simply Gum · Simply Gum
Plastic-free gum on a chicle tree-sap base, sweetened only with xylitol (two pieces, 2 g sugar alcohol on the label). Sold mostly in six 15-piece packs; the priciest per piece here.
Suggest a change
Related comparisons
-
Kids' electric toothbrushesA kids' electric toothbrush mainly helps children brush for the full two minutes and reach every tooth. This grid compares 8 popular US kids' electric and battery brushes by power source, cleaning motion, minimum age, timer, pacer, pressure sensor, battery life, warranty and price, so you can pick between a one-piece battery brush and a rechargeable with sensors.
-
Kids' toothpastesChildren's toothpaste is one product with two jobs: cleaning small teeth and, for most pastes, delivering a small dose of fluoride to prevent cavities. This grid compares 12 popular US kids' pastes by active ingredient and strength, ADA Seal, the age on the label and on the pack, swallowing guidance, sweeteners, dyes, flavor and price per ounce, so you can match a paste to your child's age and your family's priorities.
-
Orthodontic wax and braces careBraces trap food, rub the inside of the cheeks and lips, and make brushing slower. This grid compares the main things people buy to cope: orthodontic wax and a silicone wax alternative for the poking wire or bracket, complete braces kits that bundle a toothbrush, interdental brushes and wax, and individual tools such as a braces toothbrush and a flosser built for brackets. It shows what is in each box, what it costs, and which problems it solves, so you can match a product to your braces and your orthodontist's advice.
-
Fluoride mouthwashesA fluoride mouthwash adds fluoride after brushing to help prevent cavities, which can matter for braces, dry mouth and people prone to decay. This grid compares 11 popular US anticavity rinses by fluoride strength, how often you rinse, ADA Seal, alcohol, minimum age, dyes, sweeteners and price per ounce, so you can match a rinse to your family.
-
ToothpastesEvery toothpaste cleans, but they differ in what else they do: stannous fluoride pastes also fight gingivitis and sensitivity, peroxide and baking soda pastes chase stains, and fluoride-free hydroxyapatite pastes appeal to people avoiding fluoride. This grid compares 27 popular US toothpastes by active ingredient, labeled uses, foaming agent, sweeteners, minimum age and price per ounce, so you can match a tube to your teeth, gums and budget.
-
Toothpaste tablets and zero-waste oral careToothpaste tablets swap the tube for a small dry tablet: you chew one, brush with a wet toothbrush, and it foams into paste. They suit travel, plastic-free routines and people who dislike tubes, but they differ on the things that matter for teeth: some contain fluoride, others use nano-hydroxyapatite; some ship in compostable pouches with a refillable jar; and monthly cost varies a lot. This grid compares the main tablets sold to US buyers with the ingredients, packaging and prices the makers publish.