Winter boots

Winter boots keep your feet warm and dry in snow, slush and cold. This grid compares insulated, waterproof men's boots from Merrell, Timberland, The North Face, KEEN, Muck and Baffin by insulation, stated temperature rating, weight and price.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with how you will use them. Standing or sitting in the cold (ice fishing, watching games) needs far more insulation than walking, because moving makes heat and sweat.

Key questions

  • How cold does it get? Makers rate boots differently, so treat a temperature rating as a rough guide for moderate activity. Compare insulation grams only within the same brand.
  • Slush or dry snow? Rubber shells and pull-ons shed slush; leather boots need regular waterproofing care.
  • How much walking? Heavy, tall boots tire you out. Light leather boots suit commuting and short trails.
  • Traction on ice? Check the outsole name; some makers use specialist ice-grip rubber.
  • Fit. Insulated boots need room for thick socks and some run large or small; read the size note on the page.

Before you buy, check the full cost, the return policy for worn-in tests indoors, and whether a removable liner can be replaced.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$170
$312
$140
$185
$150
$230
$170
$200
$250
$129.99
$200
$179
$220
⠿
Insulation
5 mm neoprene bootie, fleece lining, 2 mm foam
Removable multi-layer liner, aluminum heat layers
200 g PrimaLoft Gold Eco, fleece lining
200 g synthetic, aerogel insole, fleece lining
400 g PrimaLoft, teddy fleece lining
Faux shearling lining; no grams stated
400 g Heatseeker synthetic
200 g KEEN.WARM recycled PET
9 mm ThermoPlus felt innerboot
200 g
High-performance insulation (amount not stated)
PrimaLoft
None stated; 5 mm neoprene upper
⠿
Temperature rating
-40 to 40°F comfort range
-49 to -76°F (polar rated)
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
-25°F (-32°C)
Not stated
-25°F (-32°C)
Not stated
Not stated
Comfort from 5°F (-15°C)
⠿
Waterproofing
100% waterproof rubber boot
B-TEK Dry waterproof base, rubber shell
Waterproof membrane
Waterproof membrane
TimberDry waterproof membrane
Waterproof leather, seam-sealed
Waterproof, seam-sealed molded TPU shell
KEEN.DRY waterproof, breathable membrane
Seam-sealed waterproof leather, vulcanized rubber shell
Waterproof leather, seam-sealed
Waterproof membrane
Leather upper on rubber bottom
Waterproof neoprene construction
⠿
Upper material
Rubber with neoprene
Leather and nylon
Waterproof full-grain leather
Waterproof leather and mesh
Waterproof Timberland leather
Waterproof Timberland leather
Full-grain waterproof leather and suede
Waterproof leather and performance mesh
Waterproof leather with rubber shell
Waterproof leather, injection-molded shell
Premium leather
Leather upper and lining
5 mm Neo-Tech neoprene
⠿
Closure
Pull-on with pull tab
Double buckle
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Lace-up
Bungee closure
Lace-up
Pull-on with pull tab
⠿
Outsole
Self-cleaning MS-1 lug
Polar Rubber
Merrell Sticky Rubber (winter)
Vibram Arctic Grip or XS Trek Evo
Rubber lug
Rubber lug
Surface CTRL winter rubber
KEEN.POLAR Traction, 5 mm lugs
Aerotrac natural rubber
Omni-Grip rubber
Multidirectional lugs
TPE outsole
Vibram Arctic Grip
⠿
Boot height
12 in
15 in
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
6 in
Not stated
4.53 in
10.5 in
8.25 in
Not stated
8 in
Not stated
⠿
Weight per boot
2.5 lb
3.71 lb
1.03 lb
1.23 lb
1.73 lb
2.07 lb
1.57 lb
1.52 lb
2.69 lb
1.75 lb
Not stated
1.53 lb
Not stated
⠿
Removable liner
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Warranty
1 year limited
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Limited lifetime
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Ice grip outsole
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Winter boots span about $140 to $310; pay for warmth you will actually need.

  • Insulation

    Insulation is what keeps your feet warm standing still; more is not better if you are active and sweat.

  • Temperature rating

    A maker rating is a rough guide for moderate activity; cold feet depend on socks, circulation and how still you stand.

  • Waterproofing

    Melting snow and slush soak non-waterproof boots fast; a rubber shell or membrane keeps feet dry.

  • Upper material

    Leather lasts and wipes clean; rubber and nylon shed slush; each needs different care.

  • Closure

    Laces give a tuned fit; pull-on boots are fast but fit looser; buckles work with gloves.

  • Outsole

    Grip on ice and packed snow depends on the rubber and lug design.

  • Boot height (in)

    Taller boots keep out deep snow; shorter ones are lighter and easier to walk in.

  • Weight per boot (lb)

    Heavy boots tire you on long walks; for standing or short trips weight matters less.

  • Removable liner

    A removable liner dries overnight and can be replaced when it packs down.

  • Warranty

    Tells you what the maker will repair or replace if seams or soles fail.

  • Ice grip outsole

    Ice, not snow, is what causes most winter falls; an ice-rated outsole grips wet ice far better than ordinary lugs. Matters less on deep snow or trails.

About the products

  • Arctic Sport Mid · Muck Boot Company

    Rubber and neoprene pull-on for wet, slushy cold; fleece lining and a 5 mm neoprene bootie. Best for chores and dog walks in deep cold, not long hikes.

  • Impact · Baffin

    Polar-rated 15 in boot with a removable multi-layer liner you can dry overnight. For extreme cold and low to moderate activity; heavy and pricey. The page showed it sold out when checked.

  • Thermo Kiruna 2 Mid · Merrell

    Light leather winter hiker with 200 g insulation. Suits snowy trails and commutes in moderate cold; not meant for deep freeze.

  • Coldpack 3 Thermo Mid · Merrell

    Leather and mesh winter boot with 200 g insulation, an aerogel insole and Vibram traction for icy ground. A step up in grip from the Kiruna.

  • Chillberg Waterproof Winter Boot · Timberland

    Insulated leather hiking-style boot with 400 g PrimaLoft; the warmest insulation among the lace-up leather boots here, at a mid price.

  • Premium 6-Inch Waterproof Warm-Lined Boot · Timberland

    The classic yellow-boot look with a faux shearling lining. Town and light snow wear; no insulation rating is given.

  • Chilkat V 400 Waterproof Boots · The North Face

    A leather and suede lace-up with 400 g of synthetic insulation, the warmest in this grid's lace-ups, and a heel clip for snowshoes. No temperature rating or shaft height is published.

  • Revel IV Mid Polar Waterproof Boot · KEEN

    A light winter hiker with 200 g insulation rated to -25°F and an ice-grip outsole. Its ankle-height shaft (about 4.5 in) keeps out less deep snow than taller boots.

  • Caribou · Sorel

    Classic felt-lined, waterproof leather and rubber-shell snow boot with a removable 9 mm felt innerboot; warm and heavy, best for cold, wet walking rather than long hikes.

  • Bugaboot III · Columbia

    Lace-up winter hiker with 200 g insulation and a waterproof leather upper; light for a rated -25°F boot and a budget-friendly price. Also sold in wide.

  • Crosstrak Powder Waterproof · Salomon

    High-cut leather winter hiker with a waterproof membrane, insulation and bungee closure for quick, glove-friendly on and off; the maker gives no temperature rating.

  • Bean Boots 8" Insulated · L.L.Bean

    Maine-made leather-and-rubber lace-up with PrimaLoft insulation; a classic, lighter than most pac boots, with a sized-down fit.

  • Bozeman II Vibram Arctic Grip · Bogs

    Pull-on waterproof neoprene mid-calf boot with Vibram Arctic Grip outsole for slick ice; a mediumweight chore and snow-shoveling boot rather than an arctic one (comfort range from 5°F).

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons