Pain relievers

Compare common OTC pain relievers, from acetaminophen (Tylenol), ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin), naproxen (Aleve) and aspirin (Bayer) to the Excedrin combination, diclofenac gel and a lidocaine patch. See onset, dosing interval, daily maximum, age limits and who should avoid each one (stomach, liver, kidney, blood thinners, pregnancy). Acetaminophen is not an anti-inflammatory; the NSAIDs are.

Last updated

How to choose

Match the label to the pain

Acetaminophen is labeled for minor pain and fever but is not an anti-inflammatory. Oral NSAIDs such as ibuprofen, naproxen, and aspirin are labeled for several minor aches and pains; topical diclofenac has a narrower label for arthritis pain in specified joints.

Read the exact directions

These labels differ in dose intervals, daily limits, age cutoffs, and how long self-treatment should continue. Use the product package you have, and do not combine products with the same active ingredient or multiple NSAIDs unless a health professional tells you to.

Check warnings before use

Acetaminophen labels warn about liver damage and taking other acetaminophen-containing medicines. NSAID labels warn about serious stomach bleeding and cardiovascular risks; aspirin also has a Reye syndrome warning for children and teenagers with chickenpox or flu-like symptoms. Ask a pharmacist or clinician about personal conditions, pregnancy, medicines, or uncertainty. This grid summarizes selected Drug Facts information and is not medical advice.

Quick screens before you buy

  • Stomach, kidney or blood thinners: oral NSAIDs (ibuprofen, naproxen, aspirin) carry stomach-bleeding warnings and tell people with kidney disease to ask first. Acetaminophen and the lidocaine patch have no such warnings.
  • Liver or daily alcohol: acetaminophen products carry a liver warning; check every medicine you take for a second acetaminophen source.
  • Kids and teens: aspirin products warn against use in children and teens with chickenpox or flu-like illness; the adult labels here start at age 12 (18 for the arthritis products).
  • Dosing rhythm: Aleve and Tylenol 8 HR spread doses further apart than ibuprofen or standard Tylenol, which may suit all-day pain.
  • One joint or one spot: a topical gel or patch acts locally, but each has a narrow label.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$11.52, 100 caplets
$2.18, 100 tablets, Equate
$12.84, 90 caplets
$1.37, 100 coated tablets, Equate
$19.98, 100 g tube
$10.98, 100 tablets
$9.94, 100 caplets
$13.42, 100 caplets
$11.89, 100 caplets
$11.37, 6 patches
$7.32, 100 tablets
⠿
Active ingredient and strength
Acetaminophen 500 mg per caplet
Ibuprofen 200 mg per tablet (NSAID)
Naproxen sodium 220 mg per caplet (naproxen 200 mg; NSAID)
Aspirin 325 mg per tablet (NSAID)
Diclofenac sodium 1% topical gel (NSAID; 0.93% diclofenac equivalent)
Ibuprofen 200 mg per tablet (NSAID)
Ibuprofen 200 mg per tablet (NSAID)
Acetaminophen 250 mg, aspirin 250 mg (NSAID) and caffeine 65 mg per caplet
Acetaminophen 650 mg per extended-release caplet
Lidocaine 4% topical patch (local anesthetic, not an NSAID)
Aspirin 325 mg per tablet (NSAID)
⠿
Labeled OTC uses
Temporary minor aches and pains, including headache, arthritis, toothache, and backache; also fever
Temporary minor aches and pains, including headache, toothache, backache, cramps, and arthritis; also fever
Temporary minor aches and pains, including arthritis, muscle aches, backache, cramps, and headache; also fever
Temporary relief of headache, toothache, muscle, menstrual, arthritis, and cold-related pain
Temporary arthritis pain relief only for hand, wrist, elbow, foot, ankle, or knee; not immediate
Temporary minor aches and pains, including headache, toothache, backache, cramps, cold, and arthritis; also fever
Temporary minor aches and pains, including headache, toothache, backache, cramps, cold, and arthritis; also fever
Temporary minor aches and pains, including headache, cold, arthritis, muscle aches, toothache, and menstrual cramps
Temporary minor aches and pains (arthritis, muscle, back, cramps, cold, headache, toothache); also fever
Temporary pain relief at the patch site; box lists back, neck, shoulders, knees and elbows
Temporary relief of headache, toothache, muscle, menstrual, arthritis, and cold-related pain
⠿
Adult directions
Oral: 2 caplets every 6 hours; maximum 6 caplets in 24 hours
Oral: 1 tablet every 4 to 6 hours; if needed 2; maximum 6 tablets in 24 hours
Oral: 1 caplet every 8 to 12 hours; first dose may be 2; maximum 3 caplets in 24 hours
Oral: adults and children 12+; 1 to 2 tablets every 4 hours or 3 every 6 hours; maximum 12 tablets in 24 hours
Topical: apply 2 g to upper-body joints or 4 g to lower-body joints four times daily; use no more than 2 body areas
Oral: 1 tablet every 4 to 6 hours; if needed 2; maximum 6 tablets in 24 hours
Oral: 1 tablet every 4 to 6 hours; if needed 2; maximum 6 tablets in 24 hours
Oral: 2 caplets every 6 hours with a full glass of water; maximum 8 caplets in 24 hours
Oral: 2 caplets every 8 hours, swallowed whole; maximum 6 caplets in 24 hours
Topical: 1 patch at a time, up to 3 to 4 times daily; remove after 8 hours at most
Oral: adults and children 12+; 1 or 2 tablets every 4 hours or 3 every 6 hours; maximum 12 tablets in 24 hours
⠿
Self treatment age and duration limits
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Avoid in children/teens with chickenpox or flu-like symptoms; ask if pain >10 days or fever >3 days
Adults 18+; use for up to 21 days unless directed by a doctor; stop if no relief after 7 days; only specified joints
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Adults and children 12+; under 12 ask a doctor; not for children or teens with chickenpox or flu-like symptoms
Adults 18+; under 18 ask a doctor; stop and ask if pain lasts over 10 days or fever over 3 days
Adults and children 12+; under 12 consult a doctor; stop and ask if symptoms persist over 7 days
Not for children/teens with chickenpox or flu-like symptoms; under 12 consult a doctor; ask if pain >10 days
⠿
Key label warnings
Liver damage risk if over 4,000 mg/day, with other acetaminophen medicines, or with 3+ alcoholic drinks daily
Serious stomach bleeding; higher heart attack, heart failure, and stroke risk with excess dose or duration.
Serious stomach bleeding; higher heart attack, heart failure, and stroke risk with excess dose or duration.
NSAID stomach-bleeding warning; Reye syndrome warning for some children and teenagers; severe allergy warning
For external use only; NSAID cardiovascular and stomach-bleeding warnings; may take up to 7 days to work
Serious stomach bleeding; higher heart attack, heart failure, and stroke risk with excess dose or duration.
Serious stomach bleeding; higher heart attack, heart failure, and stroke risk with excess dose or duration.
Liver damage over 8 caplets/day; stomach bleeding; Reye syndrome in some children and teens; caffeine limit
Liver damage risk if over 6 caplets/day, with other acetaminophen medicines, or with 3+ drinks daily
External use only; not on wounds or damaged skin or with a heating pad; stop for skin reactions
NSAID stomach-bleeding warning; Reye syndrome warning for some children and teenagers; severe allergy warning
⠿
Form and route
Oral caplet
Oral tablet
Oral caplet
Oral tablet
Topical gel, applied to skin with a dosing card
Oral tablet or caplet
Oral caplet
Oral caplet
Oral extended-release caplet
Topical patch
Oral tablet
⠿
Dosing interval
6 hours
4 to 6 hours
8 to 12 hours
4 hours, or 3 tablets every 6 hours
4 times daily
4 to 6 hours
4 to 6 hours
6 hours
8 hours
Up to 8 hours per patch, 3 to 4 times daily
4 hours, or 3 tablets every 6 hours
⠿
Max daily dose
3,000 mg acetaminophen (6 caplets)
1,200 mg ibuprofen (6 tablets)
660 mg naproxen sodium (3 caplets)
3,900 mg aspirin (12 tablets)
32 g gel (4 g per lower-body area, 2 areas, 4 times daily)
1,200 mg ibuprofen (6 tablets)
1,200 mg ibuprofen (6 caplets)
2,000 mg acetaminophen, 2,000 mg aspirin, 520 mg caffeine (8 caplets)
3,900 mg acetaminophen (6 caplets)
3 to 4 patches, one at a time
3,900 mg aspirin (12 tablets)
⠿
Onset of relief
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
Up to 7 days for arthritis pain
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
30 to 60 minutes
Not stated
30 to 60 minutes
⠿
Minimum age on adult label
12 years
12 years
12 years
12 years
18 years
12 years
12 years
12 years
18 years
12 years
12 years
⠿
Kids version by same maker
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Contains caffeine
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
⠿
Stomach bleeding warning
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
⠿
Heart attack and stroke warning
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
⠿
Liver damage warning
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
⠿
Kidney disease caution
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
⠿
Blood thinner caution
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
⠿
Reye syndrome warning
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
⠿
Pregnancy caution
Ask a health professional before use if pregnant or breast-feeding
Ask a professional; avoid at 20 weeks or later unless a doctor directs
Ask a professional; avoid in the last 3 months unless a doctor directs
Ask a professional; avoid at 20 weeks or later unless a doctor directs
Ask a professional; avoid at 20 weeks or later unless a doctor directs
Ask a professional; avoid at 20 weeks or later unless a doctor directs
Ask a professional; avoid at 20 weeks or later unless a doctor directs
Not stated
Ask a health professional before use if pregnant or breast-feeding
Ask a health professional before use if pregnant or breast-feeding
Ask a professional; avoid in the last 3 months unless a doctor directs

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Store-brand generics with the same active ingredient often cost a fraction of the name brand, and pack sizes differ, so compare the price per tablet as well as the shelf price. Price matters less than choosing the right ingredient and following the label.

  • Active ingredient and strength

    Ingredient and strength determine what medicine is being compared.

  • Labeled OTC uses

    The label may cover different pain areas or symptoms; topical diclofenac has a narrower arthritis-pain use.

  • Adult directions

    Dosing intervals and daily limits differ; follow the specific package directions.

  • Self treatment age and duration limits

    Age, duration, or limited application area can affect whether the self-care label fits.

  • Key label warnings

    Warnings can include liver injury, stomach bleeding, cardiovascular risk, allergy, or use restrictions.

  • Form and route

    Oral products work through the body, topical ones act locally on a joint or area, which changes the side-effect profile and where it can be used.

  • Dosing interval

    A longer interval means fewer doses a day, which matters for sleep, work and avoiding accidental overdose.

  • Max daily dose

    The daily ceiling is the main overdose guard; stay under it and never add another product with the same ingredient.

  • Onset of relief

    Fast onset helps for sudden pain; slower products suit steady daily arthritis pain.

  • Minimum age on adult label (years)

    Sets who in a household can use the product.

  • Kids version by same maker

    Children cannot use adult tablets; a children's liquid or chewable is the usual route.

  • Contains caffeine

    Caffeine can boost headache relief but causes jitters or sleeplessness in some people.

  • Stomach bleeding warning

    Oral NSAIDs raise stomach bleeding risk, especially for people 60 and older, on blood thinners or drinking alcohol daily.

  • Heart attack and stroke warning

    Matters if you have heart disease, high blood pressure or past stroke.

  • Liver damage warning

    Acetaminophen overdose is a leading cause of liver injury, so daily limits and alcohol matter.

  • Kidney disease caution

    Kidney disease changes which pain relievers are safe.

  • Blood thinner caution

    Blood thinners plus pain relievers can raise bleeding risk or change drug levels.

  • Reye syndrome warning

    Aspirin should not be given to kids or teens with viral illness.

  • Pregnancy caution

    Pregnancy changes which pain relievers are appropriate; ask a clinician.

About the products

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons