Heat pumps

Compare leading U.S. ducted air-source heat pump systems by efficiency, low-temperature heating, modulation, sound, refrigerant, and warranty. Published maximum ratings are achieved only with eligible matched components; ask a licensed HVAC contractor for a load calculation and AHRI-rated match for your home.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with a room-by-room heating and cooling load calculation, duct inspection, and the coldest outdoor temperature your home must handle. Oversizing can shorten cycles and reduce humidity control; undersizing can leave electric backup running often.

Compare SEER2 for cooling and HSPF2 for seasonal heating, then check the exact matched system in the AHRI directory. A product family’s “up to” rating may require a particular air handler, coil, thermostat, and size. Cold-weather capacity and efficiency matter more in colder climates; look for published performance at low outdoor temperatures, not just the operating limit.

Single-stage systems run at full output when on; two-stage and variable-speed systems can adjust output to changing demand. More modulation can smooth temperatures and reduce cycling, though it may require communicating controls and add service complexity. Review the sound rating, thermostat and communicating-control requirements, refrigerant type, electrical needs, and registered warranty. Installation quality and local service support are part of the system choice.

Have a qualified contractor confirm sizing, duct compatibility, electrical service, refrigerant-safety requirements, incentives, and the installed cost for your home.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
System Configuration
Ducted split-system variable-speed heat pump; paired with Infinity System Control and a matched indoor unit.
Ducted split-system heat pump with a single-stage compressor; use a matched indoor system for rated performance.
Ducted split heat pump; older spec requires Lennox communicating variable-speed indoor unit and thermostat.
Ducted split heat pump; Trane UX360 thermostat and system controller required.
Ducted split heat pump; pair with IDS Ultra air handler, compatible furnace, or communication kit.
Ducted R-32 split-system heat pump; matched indoor equipment is required for complete-system ratings.
Ducted split-system heat pump; complete-system efficiency depends on matched indoor equipment and installation.
Ducted split heat pump; two-stage on most sizes, while the 1.5-ton model is single-stage.
⠿
Nominal Cooling Sizes
Current product page says various sizes but does not specify the nominal tonnage range.
Carrier lists various sizes but does not give this family’s nominal tonnage range on its current product page.
2–5 tons in the manufacturer’s January 2023 spec sheet; refrigerant/model revision may differ from current page.
2, 3, 4, and 5 tons.
3–5 tons nominal; rated cooling output varies with indoor-unit match.
2, 3, 4, and 5 tons.
2, 3, 4, and 5 tons.
1.5–5 tons across listed sizes.
⠿
Maximum SEER2
up to 23 SEER2, matched-system dependent
up to 16 SEER2, ENERGY STAR certified on select sizes
up to 23 SEER2, manufacturer’s current product page, system-match dependent
Up to 22.4 SEER2, matched indoor equipment dependent.
Up to 19 SEER2, AHRI-rated system match dependent.
up to 21 SEER2, matched-system rating
up to 20 SEER2, matched-system rating
up to 15.2 SEER2, matched-system dependent
⠿
Maximum HSPF2
up to 10.5 HSPF2, matched-system dependent
up to 8.1 HSPF2, ENERGY STAR certified on select sizes
up to 10.3 HSPF2, manufacturer’s current product page, system-match dependent
Up to 10.5 HSPF2, matched indoor equipment dependent.
10 HSPF2, Region IV; 8.5 HSPF2 in Region V; match dependent.
up to 10 HSPF2, matched-system rating
up to 8.5 HSPF2, matched-system rating
up to 7.8 HSPF2, matched-system dependent
⠿
Cold Weather Heating
Heating operation published down to −13°F; this is an operating limit, not a capacity rating.
Current Carrier product page does not publish a lowest heating temperature or low-temperature capacity for 27SCA5.
Older sheet gives 21,200–60,000 Btu/h family heating capacity, without an outdoor-temperature rating point.
Trane’s current U.S. 5TWV0 page and brochure publish no low-temperature heating limit or capacity.
100% heating capacity at 5°F (2.1 COP); operates to −13°F, the stated low-temperature limit.
Heating operating limit is −20°F; capacity at that limit is not specified here.
One listed 2-ton matched system delivers 20,000 Btu/h at 17°F; lowest operating temperature is not stated.
2.5-ton WP14AY30AJ2NA publishes 16,000 Btu/h at 17°F; this is size-specific capacity, not the family range.
⠿
Compressor Modulation
Variable-speed compressor; manufacturer says it runs from 30–100% capacity.
Single-stage compressor; no variable capacity range is published.
Variable-capacity compressor; the current product page does not publish a modulation percentage range.
Variable speed; compressor speed changes in 0.1% increments; capacity range is not stated.
Continuously variable inverter; fully modulates from minimum to maximum in 1% increments.
Adaptive inverter adjusts capacity automatically; no modulation percentage stated.
Variable-speed inverter compressor: 40–100% cooling capacity, with up to 115% overdrive in extreme conditions.
Two-stage high/low compressor on sizes above 1.5 tons; 1.5-ton variant is single-stage.
⠿
Outdoor Sound Rating
As low as 53 decibels; manufacturer page does not identify sound metric or test condition.
As low as 70 decibels; Carrier does not identify sound power/pressure metric or test condition.
Current page: as low as 57 dB; its specs table lists 58, and neither identifies the metric/test.
51–75 dB(A) overall sound power level; brochure gives no test condition.
As low as 39.9 dB(A) sound power at minimum load (3-ton heating); test method not stated.
71 dBA minimum normal-cooling sound power for 2–3 ton models; AHRI 270 compliant.
As low as 58 dB manufacturer sound rating; brochure does not identify weighting or test method.
As low as 72 dB; internal R&D test (May 2022); sound power/pressure metric not specified.
⠿
Refrigerant
Puron Advance (R-454B) on current U.S. product literature.
Puron Advance™ (R-454B); current product page identifies Puron Advance as this model’s refrigerant.
Conflict: current page narrative says R-454B, but its specs table and 2023 model sheet say R-410A; revision unclear.
R-454B.
R-454B (A2L).
R-32.
R-454B.
R-454B; integrated Refrigerant Detection System™ monitors low-GWP refrigerant.
⠿
Registered Warranty
Eligible registered systems: 10-year parts-only or 5-year parts plus 3-year labor option; terms vary by jurisdiction.
Timely registration: 10-year parts or eligible 5-year parts plus 3-year labor; otherwise generally 5-year coverage.
10-year limited compressor and covered-component warranty per current page; registration terms not stated there.
Registered: 12-year compressor, 10-year outdoor coil/parts; register within 60 days; labor excluded.
10-year residential parts/compressor coverage; 90-day labor allowance if registered within 90 days; gateway is 2 years.
Registered within 60 days: 12-year parts and 6-year unit replacement; annual maintenance required for unit coverage.
10-year parts warranty plus 10-year conditional unit replacement; registration required for unit replacement.
Registration provides 10-year conditional parts and compressor coverage.

Why these features matter

  • System Configuration

    The outdoor unit is only one part of the system. Controls and indoor equipment determine compatibility, comfort, and which published ratings apply.

  • Nominal Cooling Sizes

    Size options help narrow a shortlist, but a contractor must size the system from the home’s heat loss and gain.

  • Maximum SEER2 (SEER2)

    SEER2 compares seasonal cooling efficiency under a standard test; the top rating may depend on a specific indoor match.

  • Maximum HSPF2 (HSPF2)

    HSPF2 compares seasonal heating efficiency, though real performance varies with climate, sizing, and installation.

  • Cold Weather Heating

    An operating limit does not show how much heat remains available. Low-temperature capacity helps determine backup heat needs.

  • Compressor Modulation

    More modulation can improve comfort and part-load efficiency, but may add controls or service requirements.

  • Outdoor Sound Rating

    Sound matters near bedrooms, patios, property lines, and noise-sensitive neighbors; sound power and sound pressure ratings are not directly comparable.

  • Refrigerant

    Refrigerant affects installation requirements, service availability, and environmental impact over the system lifetime.

  • Registered Warranty

    Coverage can depend on timely registration, matched components, and professional installation, and it varies by part.

About the products

  • Infinity 23 Heat Pump (27VNA3) · Carrier

    Variable-speed ducted split heat pump with Greenspeed Intelligence and Puron Advance refrigerant.

  • Carrier Comfort 16 Heat Pump (27SCA5) · Carrier

    Single-stage ducted split heat pump positioned as an affordable current Carrier system.

  • SL25XPV Heat Pump · Lennox

    Variable-capacity ducted split heat pump; verify the exact model revision and matched indoor equipment.

  • 20 TruComfort Heat Pump (5TWV0) · Trane

    Variable-speed ducted split system with Trane Link controls and R-454B refrigerant.

  • IDS Ultra · Bosch Home Comfort

    Cold-climate ducted split heat pump designed to retain heating capacity at low outdoor temperatures.

  • FIT Aurora (DH9VS) · Daikin Comfort

    R-32 inverter-driven ducted split system with low-temperature heating and a matched indoor unit.

  • Endeavor Prestige RP19AY · Rheem

    Current R-454B, variable-speed Prestige family; linked official model listing is the 5-ton RP19AY60AJVCA.

  • Endeavor Select WP14AY · Rheem

    Current two-stage, R-454B Select family with 1.5- to 5-ton nominal sizes.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons