Eyeliners

Compare liquid, felt-tip, and pencil eyeliners by price, formula format, water resistance, shade selection, and applicator design.

Last updated

How to choose

Choose a pencil for tightlining or a smudged edge, or a liquid liner for defined wings. Felt and brush tips offer different levels of flexibility and control. If you need staying power, compare the maker’s waterproof claims; these claims describe the formula, not a guarantee for every eye shape or condition.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿ ⠿
⠿
Price
$8
$8
$10.99
$11.99
$25
$24
$22
$10.99
$11.99
$8.99
⠿
Format
Inkwell liquid liner
Liquid felt-tip pen
Sharpenable gel pencil
Mechanical gel pencil
Liquid felt-tip pen
Gel pencil
Brush-tip liquid liner
Liquid pen
Liquid pen
Mechanical pencil
⠿
Waterproof
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Yes
⠿
Shade selection
8 bold shades
Black and Chestnut Brown
16 pigment-rich shades
8 shades
Black, brown, white, blue, green, purple and pink shades
Matte, shimmer and sparkle colors including black, brown, blue, green and purple
Selected shade: Black
2 shades (pitch black, pitch brown)
3 shades (jet black, matte black, brown)
5 shades (onyx, cinnabar, pewter, sapphire, espresso)
⠿
Applicator and tip
Precision felt tip wand
Precision felt tip
Sharpenable pencil; creamy gel
Twist-up pencil with built-in smudger
Precision felt tip
Retractable gel pencil; smudge, then set
Fine flexible brush tip
Flex-tip brush; hexagonal grip
Not stated
Twist-up pencil; no sharpening
⠿
Smudge and wear claims
Long-lasting and quick-drying; waterproof claim, no smudge-proof claim stated
Smudge-proof color; quick-dry and long-lasting formula
Waterproof, smudge resistant, fade resistant, and sebum resistant
Smudge-resistant, waterproof wear up to 36 hours
Waterproof, smudge-proof, transfer-proof; stays in place all day
12-hour wear; fade-proof; waterproof
Long-lasting waterproof formula; resists fading, feathering and flaking
Up to 24 hours; doesn't smudge
Waterproof; smudge, flake and fade resistant; up to 24 hours
Waterproof and smudge-resistant; stays true all day
⠿
Wear time claim
Not stated
Not stated
36 hr
36 hr
Not stated
12 hr
Not stated
24 hr
24 hr
Not stated
⠿
Vegan formula
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Yes
No
⠿
Ophthalmologist tested
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Yes
Not stated
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
Not stated
Yes

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Shows the upfront cost.

  • Format

    The format affects line control, portability, and how the product is applied.

    Liquid
    : Wet liner in a pen or pot. Gives the sharpest line and wings; takes a steadier hand and dries in seconds.
    Gel pencil
    : Creamy pencil that glides on and can be smudged briefly before it sets. Easier for beginners and for lining the waterline.
    Mechanical
    : Twist-up pencil that never needs a sharpener; the tip can wear blunt, so lines are softer.
    Sharpenable
    : Needs sharpening for a fine point, which keeps detail precise but wastes a little product.
  • Waterproof

    Useful for wear in humidity, tears, or water.

  • Shade selection

    Color choice affects how well a liner suits everyday or creative looks.

  • Applicator and tip

    Tip style affects line width and precision.

  • Smudge and wear claims

    An explicit smudge or wear claim helps set expectations about transfer and how long the line may last.

  • Wear time claim (hr)

    A longer claim suggests staying power, but these are maker lab claims; oily lids and rubbing shorten them.

  • Vegan formula

    Matters if you avoid animal-derived ingredients; many pencils use beeswax.

  • Ophthalmologist tested

    A useful sign for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, though it is a maker claim, not a guarantee against irritation.

About the products

  • H2O Proof Inkwell Eyeliner · e.l.f. Cosmetics

    Cheapest way to get a waterproof liquid liner: a felt-tip wand in an inkwell pot, in 8 bold shades. Vegan and cruelty free; makes no smudge-proof claim.

  • H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen · e.l.f. Cosmetics

    Budget waterproof felt-tip liquid pen with a smudge-proof matte finish, in black and brown. Vegan and cruelty free.

  • Tattoo Studio Sharpenable Longwear Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil · Maybelline

    Sharpenable waterproof gel pencil with up to 36 hours of claimed wear and 16 shades, including shimmer and chrome finishes.

  • Infallible Grip Mechanical Gel Eyeliner Pencil · L’Oréal Paris

    Twist-up gel pencil with a built-in smudger, 8 shades, and up to 36 hours of claimed waterproof wear. Ophthalmologist tested for sensitive eyes.

  • Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner · Stila

    Prestige felt-tip liquid liner with the widest shade range here, from black to white, blue, green and purple. Waterproof, smudge-proof and transfer-proof; Leaping Bunny certified.

  • Stay All Day Smudge & Set Waterproof Gel Eye Liner · Stila

    Retractable waterproof gel pencil you can smudge then set, with 12-hour wear. Waterline safe and ophthalmologist tested; Leaping Bunny certified.

  • Perfect Strokes Matte Liquid Liner · Rare Beauty

    Matte liquid liner with a fine, flexible brush tip and a waterproof formula that resists fading, feathering and flaking.

  • Hyper Easy Liquid Eyeliner · Maybelline

    Drugstore brush-tip liquid pen with a hexagonal grip, made for beginners who want a smooth, no-skip line in black or brown.

  • Tattoo Studio Ink Pen Eyeliner · Maybelline

    Waterproof, vegan liquid liner pen with up to 24 hours of wear, in black and brown.

  • Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil · Maybelline

    Budget twist-up pencil that never needs sharpening; waterproof, ophthalmologist tested and suited to sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Contains beeswax.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons