Tankless water heaters

Tankless water heaters heat water on demand instead of storing it in a tank, so they can run longer, save space and last years longer than a tank. The decision is gas or electric, how much flow you need for the taps running at once, and what it takes to install: a gas line, a vent, or a heavy electrical circuit. This grid compares whole-house gas and electric models from Rinnai, Navien, Rheem, Stiebel Eltron and EcoSmart.

Last updated

How to choose

Start with fuel. Gas models heat more water faster and usually cost less to run, but need a gas line big enough for the unit and a vent. Electric models need no vent, are small and cheap to buy, but need a large circuit (often 3 x 40 A) and heat less water in cold climates.

Size it

  • Add up the flow of the fixtures you run at once (a shower is about 2 gallons per minute).
  • Check the maker's flow at your temperature rise: incoming water temperature to the setting you want (for example 55°F to 120°F is a 65°F rise). Rated flow drops as the rise grows.
  • Electric units rated 4 to 7 GPM often only deliver 2 to 3 GPM in cold regions.

Check the install

  • Gas: gas pipe size, vent length and material, a drain for condensate (condensing models), outdoor or indoor placement.
  • Electric: breaker size, wire and panel capacity. A panel upgrade can add real cost.
  • Ask for a quote on the full installed price; it can match the unit price.

Compare running cost and care

  • UEF is the efficiency rating; condensing gas models score about 0.9 to 0.98.
  • Look at the heat exchanger warranty, and plan yearly flushing in hard water areas.
  • A recirculation pump gives faster hot water at the tap but uses extra energy and water pipes.

Check federal and local rebates; ENERGY STAR models may qualify.

Answer

Browse the table. Filter to what matters.

Use the filters below, then sign in if you want to shortlist and decide with friends.

Sign in to vote

Sign in to vote, hide products and features, and reorder.

Verified: hover a cell and click its green dot for the source Estimate: no cited source Not stated: the maker doesn't publish it

FeatureProduct ⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿
Links
⠿ ⠿
Links
⠿
Price
$1,500
$700
$2,433
$1,264.20
$1,419.87
$2,199
$1,849
$959
$609.99
⠿
Fuel
Natural gas
Electric
Natural gas or propane
Natural gas or propane
Natural gas
Natural gas or propane (conversion)
Natural gas or propane (conversion)
Electric
Electric
⠿
Maximum flow rate
9.5 GPM, at 35°F rise
4.3 GPM, at about 38°F rise
11.1 GPM
7.1 GPM
7.5 GPM
11.2 GPM, at 35°F rise
8.4 GPM, at 35°F rise
4.5 GPM, at 37°F rise (240 V)
7.4 GPM, at 25°F rise
⠿
Maximum gas input
199,900 BTU/hr
Doesn't apply
199,000 BTU/hr
130,000 BTU/hr
160,000 BTU/hr
199,900 BTU/hr
150,000 BTU/hr
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
⠿
Maximum electric power
Doesn't apply
24 kW
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
24 kW
27 kW
⠿
UEF
0.93
0.93
0.98
0.97
0.89
0.95
0.95
0.97
0.93
⠿
Condensing
Yes
Doesn't apply
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Doesn't apply
Doesn't apply
⠿
ENERGY STAR
Not stated
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Not stated
Not stated
⠿
Venting
Direct vent; 2 in or 3 in PVC, CPVC or ABS
None needed (electric)
Direct vent or room air; 2 in PVC, CPVC or PP, or concentric
Direct vent or room air; 2 in or 3 in PVC, CPVC or PP, or concentric
Direct vent; 3 in or 4 in PVC or CPVC
Direct vent; 2 in or 3 in PVC, CPVC, PP or stainless
Direct vent; 2 in or 3 in PVC, CPVC, PP or stainless
None needed (electric)
None needed (electric)
⠿
Installation location
Indoor (outdoor with separate kit)
Indoor only
Indoor or outdoor (outdoor needs vent cap)
Indoor or outdoor (outdoor needs vent cap)
Outdoor only
Indoor or outdoor, wall-hung
Indoor or outdoor, wall-hung
Indoor, wall-mounted, frost-free area
Indoor only
⠿
Built in recirculation pump
No
No
No
No
Not stated
Yes
Yes
No
No
⠿
Wi Fi control
Built in
None listed
Optional module
Optional module
Optional module
Optional module
Optional module
None listed
None listed
⠿
Heat exchanger warranty
15 years
5 years
15 years or 12,000 hours
15 years or 12,000 hours
12 years
15 years
15 years
7 years, against leaks
Limited lifetime (whole unit, US and Canada)
⠿
Gas or electrical requirement
3/4 in gas connection; 120 V power
240 V; 3 x 40 A double-pole breakers; 8 AWG wire
3/4 in gas inlet; 120 V power
3/4 in gas inlet; 120 V power
3/4 in gas inlet; 120 V power
3/4 in gas inlet; 120 V power
3/4 in gas inlet; 120 V power
240 V; 2 x 50 A breakers; 8 AWG wire
240 V; 3 x 40 A breakers; 8 AWG wire
⠿
Weight
52.9 lb
17.8 lb
55 lb
54 lb
57.3 lb
77 lb
73 lb
16.1 lb
14.7 lb
⠿
Minimum activation flow
0.4 GPM
0.3 GPM
0.13 GPM
0.13 GPM
0.4 GPM
0.5 GPM
0.5 GPM
0.5 GPM
0.3 GPM
⠿
Maximum temperature setting
140°F
140°F
140°F
140°F
140°F
140°F
Not stated
140°F
140°F

Why these features matter

  • Price ($)

    Installation often costs as much as the unit, and gas models need venting and sometimes a larger gas line; electric models need a heavy circuit. Price alone is not the full cost.

  • Fuel

    Fuel decides your running cost and what has to be installed. Gas needs a gas line and vent; electric needs a big electrical circuit.

  • Maximum flow rate (GPM)

    More flow lets you run more showers and taps at once. Rated flow falls as incoming water gets colder, so check the flow at your own temperature rise.

  • Maximum gas input (BTU/hr)

    More input means more hot water at a given rise, and needs a gas line that can supply it (some need a larger gas pipe).

  • Maximum electric power (kW)

    Higher kW heats more water but needs a bigger circuit and a service panel that can carry it.

  • UEF

    UEF shows how much of the energy becomes hot water. The gap between 0.8 and 0.98 matters over a heater's life if you use a lot of hot water.

  • Condensing

    Condensing gas heaters are more efficient and use plastic vent pipe, but need a drain for the condensate.

  • ENERGY STAR

    ENERGY STAR gas tankless heaters can qualify for rebates and tax credits in some places.

  • Venting

    Venting decides where the heater can go and the install cost. Plastic vent pipe is cheaper and easier than metal.

  • Installation location

    Outdoor models free up indoor space and need no vent through the house, but need freeze protection in cold climates.

  • Built in recirculation pump

    A recirculation pump gives hot water at the tap faster and cuts wasted water, but can add energy use.

  • Wi Fi control

    Wi-Fi lets you see errors, usage and set temperature from your phone.

  • Heat exchanger warranty (years)

    The heat exchanger is the costliest part. A longer warranty protects against the most expensive repair.

  • Gas or electrical requirement

    Installers have to match your gas line or electrical panel. Electric whole-house units often need a panel upgrade.

  • Weight (lb)

    A lighter unit is easier to hang on a wall for one person.

  • Minimum activation flow (GPM)

    A low activation flow means the heater fires for a trickle, so you don't get cold bursts at low flow.

  • Maximum temperature setting (°F)

    A hotter maximum helps with a large soaking tub, but 120°F is the safe default for most households.

About the products

  • RTGH-95DVELN-3 · Rheem

    Condensing natural-gas whole-house heater with built-in Wi-Fi and a 15-year heat exchanger. Rated for 9.5 GPM, so it can serve a large household with several showers running. Needs a gas line, a vent and a drain for condensate; a recirculation pump is a separate accessory.

  • RTEX-24 · Rheem

    Electric 24 kW whole-house heater that needs no vent or gas line. Output depends on how cold your incoming water is; it suits warmer climates and smaller households. Needs a heavy electrical circuit (3 x 40 A) and a 200 A service panel is recommended.

  • Sensei RX199iN · Rinnai

    Rinnai's top condensing gas model at 199,000 BTU/h and up to 11.1 GPM, with a 0.98 UEF. Installs indoors, or outdoors with a vent cap. Sold at about $1,703 at several retailers against a $2,433 list price.

  • Sensei RX130iN · Rinnai

    Smaller condensing gas model in Rinnai's Sensei line: 7.1 GPM and a 0.97 UEF at a lower price. A fit for one or two bathrooms; recirculation needs an add-on kit.

  • RUS75eN · Rinnai

    Outdoor-only condensing gas unit rated 7.5 GPM, 0.89 UEF. Good when there is no indoor wall or vent route. Rinnai's page is still live, but retailers' listings suggest it may be being phased out; check availability before buying.

  • NPE-240A2 · Navien

    Navien's largest NPE-A2 condensing gas model (199,900 BTU/h), with a built-in recirculation pump and buffer tank. Rated 11.2 GPM at a 35°F rise. Indoor or outdoor wall-hung.

  • NPE-180A2 · Navien

    Mid-size Navien condensing gas model (150,000 BTU/h, 8.4 GPM at a 35°F rise) with the same built-in recirculation pump and buffer tank as the 240A2, at a lower price.

  • Tempra 24 Plus · Stiebel Eltron

    Compact 24 kW electric heater (16 lb) with Advanced Flow Control to hold the set temperature as flow changes. No vent or gas needed. Like all electric units, its output drops when incoming water is cold.

  • ECO 27 · EcoSmart

    27 kW electric whole-house heater at the lowest price in this grid, with a limited lifetime warranty in the US and Canada. Needs three 40 A breakers; indoors only. Sold by the Rheem family's EcoSmart brand.

Suggest a change

You’ll sign in or create a free account to send it. We’ll keep what you typed.

Related comparisons